The Annual Hayastan Fund Telethon: A Constructive Critique


Harut Sassounian

BY HARUT SASSOUNIAN

A few thoughts may be in order on the occasion of Hayastan All-Armenian Fund’s 20th anniversary and its 15th annual telethon. The intent is not to intrude into the Fund’s internal affairs, but offer constructive criticism and suggestions that could help improve its humanitarian mission and public image.

In the absence of an elected structure representing Armenians worldwide, Hayastan Fund is the only pan-Armenian body that brings together under a single umbrella all major Armenian political, religious and community entities. The Fund’s Board of Trustees is comprised of leaders of the Republics of Armenia and Artsakh, heads of large Diaspora Armenian organizations, and prominent benefactors. As such, the Fund serves as a unique platform where all segments of the Armenian world can address their common concerns. In view of this globally singular role, the Board may wish to consider expanding the organization’s functions beyond its philanthropic activities.

The most urgent Armenian issue at this moment is the tragic condition of Syrian Armenians whose very survival is at stake, as their situation worsens on a daily basis. Hayastan Fund and its 25 affiliates worldwide should have acted much sooner by organizing an emergency telethon and donating all the proceeds to alleviate the dire needs of Syrian Armenians, be they in Syria, Armenia or elsewhere.

After much delay, the Fund decided to allocate 10% of the amount it would collect to Syrian Armenians. This small percentage, compared to the vast needs of that threatened community, disappointed many potential donors. Instead of assuming collective responsibility for this unwise decision and reversing it, the Fund’s representatives engaged in unnecessary finger pointing. When complaints from the public grew louder, some of the Fund’s affiliates grudgingly revised the 10% quota to an unspecified portion of the total amount raised, after setting aside the funds earmarked for other projects. Also, the Fund allowed donors the option of designating 100% of their contributions to Syrian relief. Of course, it would have been preferable if Hayastan Fund had designated all donations to Syrian Armenians, except those earmarked by donors for other projects.

The situation became more confusing when Bedros Terzian, Chairman of Armenia Fund in France, made a surprising announcement at the conclusion of the Fund’s European phonethon (fundraising by telephone) on November 18. In an euphoric mood, he promised to allocate a portion of the $1.8 million raised to reconstruct housing for Armenians in Aleppo after the war! Mr. Terzian, a distinguished corporate executive, may not have realized that Syrian Armenians need food, medicine and other basic necessities for survival right now, rather than after the war, at which time the Armenian community may have dwindled along with its housing needs!

Now that the telethon and phonethon are over, one can take note of some interesting numbers in the announced results. Amazingly, Armenians in Armenia and Artsakh contributed $2.5 million, whereas Armenian-Americans donated only $2.1 million ($1.5 million from the West Coast and $600,000 from the East Coast). The $21.4 million announced at the end of the telethon includes all the amounts pledged or actually raised throughout the year at different fundraising events in over a dozen countries, such as the $12 million pledged by Armenian businessmen in Moscow on November 8. Another surprising number is the substantial contribution of $600,000 received from India. Since there are only a handful of Armenians in that country, there must be an interesting explanation as to the source(s) of such a large sum!

To avoid further confusion regarding the disposition of the raised funds, Hayastan Fund’s Lebanon affiliate may consider allocating the entire proceeds of its December 8 radiothon fundraiser to the thousands of Syrian Armenians refugees. The displaced Syrian Armenian families in Lebanon are in desperate need of financial assistance to pay for basic necessities as well as their children’s schooling. Lebanese Armenian schools, which are in dire financial need, are now additionally burdened with hundreds of Syrian Armenian students whose parents cannot afford to pay tuition. Keeping its collected funds in Lebanon would enable Hayastan Fund to simultaneously help the Syrian Armenian refugees, while ensuring the survival of Armenian educational institutions.

In the coming days, as Hayastan All Armenian Fund sums up the fundraising results of its worldwide affiliates, it should announce: 1) the final amount raised, 2) the breakdown of the amounts allocated to specific projects, and 3) its plans to extend immediate assistance to Syrian Armenians.

7 Responses

for “The Annual Hayastan Fund Telethon: A Constructive Critique”

  1. It would also be interesting to know how much of the money raised in the United States was donated by Armenians who were not born here. My suspicion is that most of it (at least in small individual donations) was done by the “immigrants” who still have families in Syria or Armenia and support them throughout the year. This is a double burden on some, while others clearly not contributing.

  2. Saaten Maagar says:

    Where is AGBU and other philantropic oraganizations that pride themselves to help students and education in general. Most of them are busy closing down schools rather than opening and have found a great escape in the new era of e-education. Just copy and paste a few pages on the internet and voila!, you have an education program to substitute for all the schools in the world. The people who are running these organizations are pathetic, selfish and traitors in the real sense of the word.

    • hagop hagopian says:

      I couldn’t agree with you more. In Lebanon, they closed down 33 schools, and in Cyprus the Melkonian School was robbed and the books from the library are being auctioned off on e bay by a turkish bookseller from istanbul

  3. Sevag says:

    On point as usual…!

  4. gagik says:

    I read the article and it is good harut ! i also think where money come from india i know they give but look who given and again give the name who give so much, good answer and write harut

  5. MAX GALSTAUN says:

    FROM THE ASSOCIATION OF CALCUTTA ARMENIANS :

    The donation to the fund is totally illegal by Indian Charity law which is rooted in English laws. The testators, benefactors of the Armenian Estate in Calcutta made it clear in their wills/testaments that their benefactions/donations/fund are to be used for the Armenian Poor of Calcutta. Note : Armenian Poor of Calcutta. Which is very specific. For that reason NO PERSON who lives outside Calcutta can vote or become a Committee member.
    The “donation” violates all Indian laws and will be tracked down and returned to Calcutta or the persons who “sanctioned” this donation must pay it back from their own pockets.
    I hope Hayastan Fund will read this and return the money to the Calcutta Armenians.

    • Arunava Patra says:

      Can you please give more detail regarding donation from Calcutta Armenians. Regarding this donation, some people are moving to local court. And I am sure, this donation is completely illegal. As a journalist, I am eager to cover the story in Calcutta. But I need to know the origin of this money. The Armenian authority of Kolkata is denying this contribution. So who donated the amount? I hope the report is genuine.

Leave a Reply