Seeking to be Armenian

The Near East Relief ID of orphaned Armenian Genocide survivor Aharon Meguerditchian


BY VARANT MEGUERDITCHIAN

An initiative introduced by the Armenian government to stop the reduction in numbers of its citizenry was the law of dual citizenship. The law which came into effect in 2008 ensured that while large numbers of Armenians continued to leave the country in search of a better life, they did not need to relinquish their Armenian citizenship in order to attain a new nationality and passport. At the same time the law allowed those Armenians whose forebears had escaped the Armenian Genocide and made a new life in a foreign land to become Armenian citizens while retaining the passports of their host country.

My motivation to attain Armenian citizenship is driven by my simple right to be a citizen of the nation-state of Armenia. It can best be explained through my grandfather’s story.

Aharon Meguerditchian was born in the town of Hasanbey near the city of Adana on what is today the southern Mediterranean coast of Turkey. At the age of seven his family and the families of his friends, were rounded up in the town centre by soldiers of the Ottoman Empire. That’s where Aharon’s father, Hovsep, was separated from his family. Along with all the other men of the town, his father’s hands were tied behind his back and his beard set alight as Aharon and his younger brother Manassee, just five, watched on. Aharon, Manassee and their mother, Persape, were instructed to join the caravan of women, children and the elderly in forced marches further south. A few hours into the march, Aharon was told to run as fast and as far as he could with Manassee. The instruction this time did not come from the soldiers; it came from the familiar, loving voice of his mother. Aharon and Manassee did just that: They ran as fast as they could, over the ridge and beyond, without looking back or turning around, until they were alone, until they were ‘safe’.

In a matter of hours, Aharon was no longer a child; he was Manassee’s protector. Luckily, Aharon and Manassee came across Danish missionaries, who placed them on a ship and sent them on their way to a new world. The next ten years Aharon and Manassee spent in an orphanage in Lebanon. Aharon’s journey took him from Adana to Beirut, Buenos Aires, Marseille, back to Beirut and eventually to Sydney where he passed away surrounded by family in 1985.

Despite his burning desire, Aharon never had the chance to be a contributing citizen of the Armenian state. The only ‘Armenian’ document he ever had was his Near East Relief ID provided by the orphanage. I, however, do have that opportunity. Being a citizen makes me no more Armenian but it is a right I choose to exercise and a responsibility I choose to accept.

It is not enough to simply be satisfied that there is now an independent Armenia. As descendants of survivors of the Armenian Genocide, we have a responsibility to ensure that the Armenian nation state fulfils its purpose of serving the needs and protecting the rights of the Armenian people. Armenian citizenship provides us Diasporans the legal rights to have a say in the affairs of the Armenian state. Concerns surrounding state polices on health, education, social welfare, trade, infrastructure and foreign affairs can be more legitimately raised by citizens.

It also gives us the right to put our capabilities, skills and expertise to serve and represent Armenia as fully-fledged citizens of the state where and when required on the international stage.

This should be the purpose driving Diasporans to seek Armenian citizenship and it is disappointing that not more of us are choosing to exercise that right. It was recently reported that some 21,000 Armenians applied for Armenian citizenship in 2013. This represents just a small fraction of the Diaspora and clearly more of us need to be seeking and attaining Armenian citizenship.

But just as we have a responsibility to the Armenian state, the state has a responsibility to us.

The Diaspora Ministry of Armenia website still notes that “the dual citizenship institute is a novelty in Armenia and, as every mechanism it requires more improvement, mitigation and simplification”. The passage continues “This was not intended to cause any trouble for anyone”.

A welcome acknowledgement, but six years after the dual citizenship law came into effect, merely recognizing the cumbersome nature of the process is simply not good enough. With acknowledgement comes responsibility.

My journey toward seeking Armenian citizenship was somewhat challenging. It required multiple back and forth visits to a number of Armenian Ministerial and Departmental offices including the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Department of Passports and Visas. On one of those visits I was even instructed to attain verification of my personal documents from the Armenian Embassy in Australia. The staffer was seemingly unaware that there is no Armenian diplomatic representation in Australia. Nonetheless, my application was finally submitted in July 2013 and I expect to attain my Armenian passport during my next visit to Armenia this year.

There are an estimated ten million people who identify as Armenian across the world while just over three million of these hold Armenian citizenship. Armenia must streamline the process of citizenship and actively recruit individuals. It must do so to encourage these people to contribute to the development of Armenian society and nation building from the sciences to the arts, sports and the political arena. It must do so in the interests of national security and prosperity.

After all, a nation state of ten million contributing citizens is much more influential than a state of just three million.

Varant Meguerditchian is the former executive director and president of the Armenian National Committee (ANC) of Australia. He currently works as a government relations professional in Sydney. He holds undergraduate and graduate degrees in politics and business administration and is currently completing his second master’s degree in international relations.

Authors

Discussion Policy

Comments are welcomed and encouraged. Though you are fully responsible for the content you post, comments that include profanity, personal attacks or other inappropriate material will not be permitted. Asbarez reserves the right to block users who violate any of our posting standards and policies.

4 Comments

  1. Norin Radd said:

    I would like the author to explain and perhaps go into further detail regarding the following:

    While having dual citizenship may seem wonderful in inflating the population of Armenia officially on paper, what actual good does it do in practice “on the ground” for Armenia if any at all? As the author states himself, Armenians are dispersed all over the place, in places such as the US, England, Germany, and other countries who’s national interests and objectives do not necessarily align with that of the Republic of Armenia. As such, it is well known that intelligence such as the CIA, MI6, MOSSAD, etc. love to gain human assets from diasporan communities of different ethnic groups, and Armenians are no exception. The CIA has many “Armenian” traitors that regularly work against the interests of the RoA like the whores they are, I would not be surprised to see many of these “Armenians” with dual citizenship which would make their intelligence duties all the more effective and deadly. How does the author suggest with deal with this scenario?

    Dual citizenship is ideal on paper for all the western-washed Diasporan “patriots” that love to live abroad in LA, NY, London, Berlin, Paris, until Armenia becomes “good enough” for them. However, in practice, the policy of dual citizenship creates a huge liability and national security loophole for the RoA as it strives to defend itself from foreign intelligence activities in a very ruthless geopolitical hot spot surrounded by blood thirsty enemies. Foreign traitors of “Armenian decent” should not be able to live, plot, and plan abroad against RoA while simultaneously having citizenship on equal footing with those Armenians that live in the homeland striving to make it better.

    If you want RoA citizenship, you should go to Armenia, make it your own, live there, help it grow and contribute, then and only then are you worthy of applying for citizenship and voting. Just because your last name ends with “ian” and “yan” and you are an Armenian living abroad does not give you equal rights as those Armenians struggling in the homeland while you call yourself an Armenian citizen in LA sitting at Starbucks enjoying your tall latte.

    It’s truly sad and pathetic how little value the author suggests we put on our citizenship by giving it away to Diasporans simply because they ID themselves as Armenians. RoA citizenship should be worth a lot more than what the author suggests out of nostalgia.

  2. edward demian said:

    You are so wrong. Small minded, provincial and without vision. Armenia needs the diaspora and the diaspora needs Armenia.. Your kind of shovanistic opinion really saddens me. Some of us have struggled for a thousand years to remain Armenian, outside Armenia, whille Armenians living in Armenia are speking Russian.

    • Norin Radd said:

      Great you’ve mindlessly declared I’m wrong, now answer the actual concerns then. No where above did I mention that Armenia “does not need” the Diaspora, in fact it’s the diasporas duty to shut up and help as much as possible. But riddle me this, do you actually believe that you should have equal voting rights and full fledged citizenship while living abroad on par with the Armenians struggling in the homeland? Citizenship is not necessary for the likes of you to help Armenia, if you want voting rights and citizenship then you must be a resident citizen, not an armchair pontificator. Armenia will not be governed from the outside as Diasporans would like it just so that they can continue having their lattes in Paris, Sydney, LA, and NY!

      Also, how do you propose we make sure human diasporan ROA dual “citizens” aren’t drafted by foreign intelligence agencies? There are lots of “hyes” working in the FBI and CIA, should we grant them dual citizenship as well? Let’s hear your proposals.

  3. Artin said:

    If an ethnic Armenian wants his ethnicity recognized and acknowledged, there should not be any obstacles, legal one, in his path to obtain the Armenian citizenship. For the skeptics about dual citizenship, they could very well bar those armenians , who have obtained the recognition to their ethnicity whilst living abroad, from voting in elections in Armenia until such time as they have had full residency. I know of a 70 year old ethnic Armenian who wants his citizenship of RA for the sole reason of his ethnicity. Every ethnic hay has the inalienable right to citizenship of RA, whether he lives there or not. As a matter of fact, ethnic hyes should automatically be granted citizenship or passports of RA.

*

Top