Armenia Expects Explanation for Russian Patriarch’s Statement

Armenia's Public Council member Karine Danielyan. (Source: Photolure)
Armenia's Public Council member Karine Danielyan. (Source: Photolure)

Armenia’s Public Council member Karine Danielyan. (Source: Photolure)

YEREVAN (Combined Sources) — On January 14, Public Council member Karine Danielyan proposed at the meeting of the Commission on Religion, Diaspora and International Integration Issues of the Public Council of Armenia, that Armenia needs to respond with a statement to Russian Patriarch Kirill’s statement that the Christian minorities in the Ottoman Empire were not annihilated.

The Public Council also stated that they need more explanation regarding the statement made by the Patriarch.

“We need to respond to this statement and expect a more serious explanation, since the explanation given by the Moscow Patriarchate is insufficient,” Danielyan noted.

She added that the Public Council will decide on the format of the adequate response they will demand regarding this statement by the Patriarch.

“I think that we need to petition to the Russian embassy [in Armenia’s capital city of Yerevan] with an open letter,” Danielyan said. “Now, we are working on making additions to the [respective] statement [of ours].”

The Public Council following a meeting Friday also said that they were waiting for clarifications regarding the comments made by Patriarch Kirill.

“But if we put military actions aside, which were always accompanied by a loss on all sides, what is happening now never happened in the Islamic world before. Take the example of the Ottoman Empire. Yes, there were Christian minorities, but they had not been destroyed,” said Kirill.

The Russian Patriarch’s recent TV interview, during which he had made the abovementioned statement, caused protests among the Armenian society.

Subsequently, the Patriarch’s spokesperson commented on the given part of this interview. He noted that the Russian Orthodox Church’s stance on Armenian Genocide was repeatedly expressed through official announcements and the Patriarch’s remarks, whose evidence is the Russian Orthodox Church’s participation in the Armenian Genocide Centennial commemorations in 2015.

These comments made Armenian media and social networks interpret them as an indirect denial of the Armenian Genocide.

“Nobody destroyed a million and a half of Armenians in their historic homeland, conquered and plundered by the Turks, nobody massacred Greeks and Assyrians! Is this a modern interpretation of historical facts by the Russian Orthodox Church?”  The statement by the Public Council asked.

The Public Council expressed hope that the comments by Kirill are not a tribute to the short-term political interests, but are the result of a short-term misunderstanding.

“We are delighted that this interpretation is not backed by the leadership of the Russian Federation, as evidenced by the recognition of the Armenian Genocide in the Ottoman Empire by the State Duma of Russia, as well as by the participation of Russian President Vladimir Putin in a ceremony marking the centennial of the Armenian Genocide,” the statement said.

Authors

Discussion Policy

Comments are welcomed and encouraged. Though you are fully responsible for the content you post, comments that include profanity, personal attacks or other inappropriate material will not be permitted. Asbarez reserves the right to block users who violate any of our posting standards and policies.

3 Comments

  1. bassoy said:

    But why the Commission on Religion, Diaspora and International Integration Issues of the Public Council of Armenia, would not, indeed accede to Patriarch Kirill’s deep cut statement he made during the Russian State TV interview where he stated that “…military actions aside, which were always accompanied by a loss on all sides, what is happening now never happened in the Islamic world before. Take the example of the Ottoman Empire. Yes, there were Christian minorities, but they had not been destroyed”: Patriarch Kirill rightfully spoke his mind based on his studious knowledge and assessments of history, and thus opined that “Otoman empire had not destroyed her minorities”- razing thereby the opiniated pronouncement of the present Sovereign of the Vatican City who light-headedly qualified the 1915 events of Eastern Anatolia -occurred in the course of the 1st Word War- as the” first genocide of the 20th century” to the ground.
    To what purpose would an apology from the Patriarch for his statement or an explanatory explanation that might be obtained under politico-religious pressures serve the recogntion of “Armenian genocide” allegations and “hye dat”?

    “Genocide is precisely a legal concept”. And “Armenian genocide” allegations have been legally thwarted repeatedly.
    Historical(is history science?) and political approaches are unconvincing- exposed, as they are, to controversy and subjectivity.

    Minds to be rational should acquiesce the obliging limits of the above before furthering the “Armenian genocide” and “hye dat”.

  2. Ed said:

    Unfortunately the Russian Orthodox Church still believes the non-Chalcedonian churches, such as the Armenian Church, are essentially heretics – and there is rampant anti-Catholic sentiment among many Russian Orthodox. There are of course historical and theological reasons for that, but isn’t it time we as Christians paid more attention to Jesus’ prayer that ‘we be one’ than to historical wrongs and the sin of pride, which is commonplace among the clergy?

  3. Norserunt said:

    Stop the silly nonsense, the man simply misspoke. The Russian orthodox Church has long recognized the Armenian Genocide, so has the Russian government…

*

Top