ADL’s Official Recognition of Armenian Genocide Ends Years-Long Controversy

‘What happened in the Ottoman Empire to the Arme­ni­ans beginning in 1915 was geno­cide,’ wrote ADL CEO Jonathan Greenblatt (Photo: ADL)
‘What happened in the Ottoman Empire to the Arme­ni­ans beginning in 1915 was geno­cide,’ wrote ADL CEO Jonathan Greenblatt (Photo: ADL)

‘What happened in the Ottoman Empire to the Arme­ni­ans beginning in 1915 was geno­cide,’ wrote ADL CEO Jonathan Greenblatt (Photo: ADL)

BY RUPEN JANBAZIAN
From The Armenian Weekly

ADL CEO Jonathan Greenblatt’s Op-Ed Welcomed by Armenian Community, Activists
NEW YORK—The Anti-Defamation League, the U.S. non-governmental organization self-described as “the nation’s premier civil rights/human relations agency,” has finally officially referred to what happened to the Armenian people of the Ottoman Empire in the beginning of the 20th century as “unequivocally genocide” and condemned its denial, putting an end to a nearly decade-long controversy that had marred the organization.

“What happened in the Ottoman Empire to the Arme­ni­ans begin­ning in 1915 was geno­cide. The geno­cide began with the rul­ing gov­ern­ment arrest­ing and exe­cut­ing sev­eral hun­dred Armen­ian intel­lec­tu­als. After that, Armen­ian fam­i­lies were removed from their homes and sent on death marches. The Armen­ian peo­ple were sub­jected to depor­ta­tion, expro­pri­a­tion, abduc­tion, tor­ture, mas­sacre and starvation,” wrote ADL CEO and National Director Jonathan Greenblatt, in an op-ed entitled, “ADL on the Armenian Genocide,” published on May 13 on the agency’s website. The statement stood in stark contrast to the ADL’s 2007 statement, which caused uproar not only among Armenian communities in the United States and around the world, but also within the organization itself.

Greenblatt also said that his organization would support U.S. recognition of the Armenian Genocide. “Silence is not an option,” he wrote, noting the significance of educating each generation about the “tragedies of the past.”

Dikran Kaligian, a member of the Armenian National Committee of America-Eastern Region board called Greenblatt’s op-ed and the ADL’s official affirmation of the genocide an important statement, which “clearly responds to the long-standing demand of the ANCA that the ADL unequivocally affirm the historical fact of the Armenian Genocide and support formal U.S. recognition.”

“Coming from the National Director of the ADL, who succeeded Abe Foxman, the statement helps erase the stain on the reputation of the ADL caused by Foxman’s denialist statements and lobbying against genocide resolutions,” added Kaligian, who also urged the ADL to join the growing coalition of organizations advocating for congressional resolutions for justice for the Armenian Genocide and the return of confiscated Armenian properties.

Former ADL national director Abraham H. Foxman (Photo: ADL)

Former ADL national director Abraham H. Foxman (Photo: ADL)

In a statement penned by then-ADL national director Abraham H. Foxman in August 2007, the organization said that it believed that “the consequences of those actions [of the Ottoman Empire] were indeed tantamount to genocide,” a stance that many felt fell short of full recognition. Moreover, it was revealed that the ADL—which, in 1913, was established to “stop the defamation of the Jewish people and to secure justice and fair treatment to all”—notoriously lobbied against passage of a Congressional resolution affirming the Armenian Genocide.

At the time, it was clear that the ADL shared the Turkish government’s opposition to U.S. Congress discussing and voting on a non-binding resolution affirming the Armenian Genocide.

Andrew H. Tarsy, the regional director of the Anti-Defamation League New England office at the time, announced his resignation in December 2007, after months of dispute with the national organization’s stance on the Armenian Genocide.

In light of Greenblatt’s statement, Tarsy told the Boston Globe that recognition was not enough. “I think they ought to lead the conversation about reparations for these families,” he was quoted as saying. “The recovery of assets, land, money, items, family heirlooms. Everything that Holocaust reparations… has represented should be on the table.”

Turkey’s then Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan receives the ADL’s ‘Courage to Care’ award from ADL National Director Abraham Foxman in New York. June 10, 2005. (Photo: jta.org)

Turkey’s then Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan receives the ADL’s ‘Courage to Care’ award from ADL National Director Abraham Foxman in New York. June 10, 2005. (Photo: jta.org)

At the time of the ADL’s 2007 statement, the ANCA asked the organization to remain true to its mission and fully acknowledge the genocide, refrain from advocating for Turkish calls for a “historical commission,” and express support for U.S. recognition of the crime. The ANCA also demanded an apology from Foxman for the damage and pain the ADL’s actions and statements caused.

Since the release of the 2007 statement and similar statements in the coming years, human rights activists have continuously pressed the ADL for a full acknowledgement of the genocide. Speaking to the Armenian Weekly, No Place for Denial activist and co-founder of the Coalition to Recognize the Armenian Genocide Laura Boghosian said that when Boston-area Armenians united in the No Place for Denial campaign to fight the ADL’s genocide denial in 2007, they were supported by members of the Jewish community who were disturbed by the ADL’s actions.

“Notably, the rabbis and members of Lexington’s Temple Isaiah and Boston’s Temple Israel joined with us to create the Coalition to Recognize the Armenian Genocide, whose goals were to reverse ADL policy, educate the Jewish community about the Armenian Genocide, and pursue U.S. affirmation of the genocide,” she said. “Nine years later, we are still working together and proving that grassroots activism does make a difference.”

The Coalition to Recognize the Armenian Genocide was established in 2008 to foster communication between the Armenian and Jewish communities and to raise awareness of the Armenian Genocide within the Jewish community. The organization advocates for official recognition of the genocide by the United States government. Coalition members include representatives from the ANCA and the Armenian Assembly of America (AAA).

During the initial controversy in 2007, the coalition helped facilitate contacts between Armenian activists and ADL members and created an online petition calling on the U.S. Congress to recognize the Armenian Genocide.

Nearly seven years after his initial statement, Foxman publicly recognized that the Ottoman atrocities of the Armenian people constituted genocide, during his remarks delivered at Suffolk University Law School’s commencement in 2014, though a statement was never published by the ADL confirming that this was the organization’s stance.

Aram Hamparian, the executive director of the ANCA told the Boston Globe that Greenblatt’s statement was the first time the ADL was very “explicit” in its breaking with Turkish government’s denial of the genocide. Commenting on what he called an “historic statement”, Middlesex County Sheriff Peter Koutoujian said that he was proud to be a part of a “lengthy, open dialogue” with the ADL, along with the ANCA and the AAA over the years. In his statement, Koutoujian also thanked all parties who took part in the discussions with the ADL, including ADL New England regional director Robert Trestan, who he called “a true friend and partner to all Armenians.”

Authors

Discussion Policy

Comments are welcomed and encouraged. Though you are fully responsible for the content you post, comments that include profanity, personal attacks or other inappropriate material will not be permitted. Asbarez reserves the right to block users who violate any of our posting standards and policies.

7 Comments

  1. edward demian said:

    Abraham Foxman has no idea how much he hurt Jewish Armenian relations. I hope the bribe money that he took was worth it. Because if he didn’t get any, than he’ll go down in history as one of the few stupid Jews.

  2. freakshow said:

    Does it really matter what the ADL and the AJC want to call The Armenian Genocide or even recognize it when they support bilateral relations between Israel and Azerbaijan which jeopardizes Armenian history and its future?

    We are so worried about what these organizations do to marginalize our past that we have lost sight of what they are doing now which endangers our future.

  3. serop said:

    A small step in the right direction, dont get carried away, this may very well be just a token gesture as I believe they now know that Armenians globally are taking them on and fighting their corrupt stance and support of the Genocide denial to appease the turks

  4. Ari said:

    Although this is a late and small positive step, it is still very disappointing to see the State of Israel “in bed” with the Turks on many other matters.

    All so called democratic states (including the US) must stop chasing the money and begin practicing that which they preach. Until such time, innocent people around the world will continue to suffer from consequences of injustice.

  5. Boghos said:

    The ADL has and continues to be a political organization that does the bidding of Israel. It is not a human rights group. If what was published in the Armenian Mirror Spectator on this matter is true, the ADL will be free to hold so-called human rights programs in towns that once showed it the door because of its anti-human rights stance on the Armenian Genocide. The ADL CEO’s remarks come after the discovery that the ADL entered a town that had banned it. The motivation seems to be to remove this ban more than it is to come clean and work on the side of justice. We have no guarantees that the ADL will apologize for its obstructionist activities. Nor that it will cease its work behind closed doors against Armenian justice. Nor even lobby for the Armenian Genocide resolution. The blog statement seems like a bit of cheap PR to compensate for the bad press lately over Israel arming Azerbaijan against Armenian Karabakh.

  6. mike said:

    It saddens me to hear that American-Jewish organizations, which were established to assist American Jews or like the ADL assist every victim of discrimination–Jew or non-Jew–have willingly become extensions of the Israeli government’s foreign policy and thus support Azerbaijan for the sole reason that brutal Baku is friendly with Israel these days. To gain the confidence and respect of the American public, these organizations should divest themselves from playing politics in the US on behalf of Azerbaijan or any government which this week happens to be friendly with Israel.
    It’s the type of above behavior which gives weight to the question of dual allegiance and loyalty.
    Would these Jewish organization promote North Korea if tomorrow Israel signs a trade deal with North Korea?

  7. Saro said:

    The ADL is not a human rights group.
    It sat down with Turkey for many years and they planned together how to stop Armenian genocide recognition.
    It does not matter that the ADL now comes along and issues some half-way statement.
    That does not wipe away the ADL’s sins.
    If the ADL were really a human rights group and sincere, would Armenians have had to “negotiate” with it? No.

*

Top