Conscience Asks…

Garen Yegparian
Garen Yegparian

Garen Yegparian

BY GAREN YEGPARIAN

Yesterday, I heard a Martin Luther King, Jr. quote that well describes where I and many others find myself regarding the last two weeks’ events in that proto-Armenian, Urartian, site, Yerepoonee (Yerebouni/Erebuni), and of all places, at a police facility:

“Cowardice asks the question, is it safe?

Expediency asks the question, is it politic?

Vanity asks the question, is it popular?

But, conscience asks the question, is it right?”

What to do, what to say? In Diaspora and in the homeland? I’m torn.

Does/should conscience dictate a condemnation of the action because of its fratricidal results?

Does/should conscience dictate full-throated, whole hearted support because the action represents a desperate act to draw attention to a corrupt system that is damaging Armenian statehood/state-building?

Does/should conscience dictate criticism because of the use of arms, something which many contend is never appropriate in modern, democratic societies?

Does/should conscience dictate energetic response to police misbehavior and mistreatment of peaceful protesters rallying to the location to assert their rights and use the opportunity to record their grim dissatisfaction with the oligarchs ruling the Republic of Armenia?

Does/should conscience dictate a dismissive approach?

Does/should conscience dictate learning from history? If so, which case(s)? Which governmental response to similar situations is best? U.S. examples include the 1985 bombing of MOVE headquarters in Philadelphia; the takeover of the Malheur Wildlife Refuge that ended earlier this year; Cliven Bundy’s illegal grazing of cattle and the standoff with the FBI it led to; the Waco, Texas siege of the Branch Davidians in 1993; or the Black Panther party’s armed, but totally peaceful, action at the California Capitol in 1967 that led to then governor Ronald Reagan signing a gun control law (see picture)?

The Black Panther Party at the California Capitol in 1967

The Black Panther Party at the California Capitol in 1967

There’s no question that the system in the RoA stinks to the high heavens of corruption. There’s no question that the armed takeover of the police building tugs at our Robin Hood heartstrings. There’s no question that Artsakh heroes being shot along with police being injured and killed is a VERY bad outcome. There’s no question that some activists’ hyperbolic language (describing videotaped police behavior that is actually reasonable as abusive) devalues the cause they seek to serve. There’s no question that police beating up or otherwise abusing demonstrators before, during, and/or after arrest/detention is unacceptable under any circumstance. There’s no question that the government’s ham-handed handling of the situation – the extended initial silence, shooting one of the gunmen when the latter was not acting in a hostile fashion, arresting the likes of Arsinee Khanjian, mistreating a blind detainee – undoubtedly has made it worse. There’s no question that expecting a president to resign over an action such as this is ludicrous, regardless of whether you find that president to be in office legitimately or illegitimately.

The government has sent out feelers that seem to suggest a willingness to avoid severe punishment; the two dozen people holed up in the building released their initial hostages, though authorities assert they have taken new ones, medical personnel, who had entered the building to provide treatment; supportive demonstrators have been peaceful; the government has not taken extreme measures.

But, the demonstrations have been surprisingly low in numbers; they have not even reached the levels of last year’s electric Yerevan protests. What does this mean? Do our compatriots living in the homeland, overall, not support the takeover and attendant demonstrations? If so, is that because they don’t agree with the calls for improved governance that are at the heart of this crisis, or because of the tactics used? Is apathy rampant? Have people fallen into hopelessness? Are they too distracted by the urgency of earning a living, at least those that still have jobs in the country’s messed-up economy? Has an environment of fear been created that’s analogous to the Soviet era? Are people afraid of losing what little they have?

In another vein, there is criticism of political parties and Diaspora organizations that purportedly enable the government’s misdeeds. At best, that assertion is a significant overstatement. Far more problematic is the unwillingness of activists to organize. There is an aversion among them to joining established groups AND to forming their own. Seemingly the only organization born in the current Armenian political setting, and relatively recently at that, is the “Founding Parliament” which is connected to the take-over group and has not demonstrated its efficacy yet.

Criticizing existing organizations, especially political ones, may be legitimate. But: when activists, people whose hearts and minds are in the right place and aligned with the ideology of a political group/party do not join and integrate their efforts with those of others; when they create, as a result of not joining/organizing, a false dichotomy of us-and-them, “people” vs. organizations; when the fear of being organized or being in an organization leads activists to perceive organized groups in the same way they perceive the government; then you have an impossible situation, an impasse, that will lead to the persistence of the status quo.

After all this, I’m still uncertain, I can only hope that wisdom and cool heads will prevail and some good will come of this crisis. I’m looking for other ideas and perspectives, since nothing I’ve read has been completely convincing. Please share your thoughts on this matter, extensively.

 

Authors

Discussion Policy

Comments are welcomed and encouraged. Though you are fully responsible for the content you post, comments that include profanity, personal attacks or other inappropriate material will not be permitted. Asbarez reserves the right to block users who violate any of our posting standards and policies.

7 Comments

  1. daniel said:

    Yes, finally somebody within the ARF commuinty said something out of the party’s rhe

  2. G. Nishan Gerjekian said:

    I as well am conflicted about the present situation that the Sasuni Dzarer have created.
    While I do not condone armed rebellion on one hand.
    On the other, I am tired of our leaders and oligarchs filling their pockets while the population suffers.
    This “stealing” has stifled job creation, created rampant emigration, and a gross under funding of the armed forces with regard to their proper outfitting.

  3. Peter M. said:

    I am a longtime fan of Mr. Yegparian’s point-of-view journalism. He has asked some important questions in his column, with few answers. What he needs to do now, on behalf of his readers, is take a couple of weeks off from his job, his bike rides, and nature hikes…and travel to Armenia. He can ask questions of everyone there. He can use his journalistic and analytical skills to draw conclusions. He is, after all, an opinion writer, not an objective spot news reporter. He has been around the block. He has written and thought about Armenian issues for nearly three decades. He is not an advocate of the government nor an advocate of the protesters. It would be nice to see some journalism, that comes in with no preconceived notions, as gets to the bottom of all of this.

  4. Zareh Sourouzian said:

    Too many questions with no clear answers, there remains one real answer however: after the March- One incident Mr Sarkissian should never have seized power and had to resign after the most exemplary peaceful march of tens of thousands protesters marching in the streets of Yerevan the day before and thus opening a way for a just and legal election; instead he stubbornly and criminally stuck to his illegally acquired “title”. “Sergic heratzir” was and is the only solution and answer to all your philosophical, ethical, moral, legal or patriotic questions.

  5. daniel said:

    From the number of comments posted here I can say that either people are not reading this e-journal or they have completely lost interest in matters of Armenia.
    White genocide is taking its tall and we are silently witnessing it.

*

Top