Armenia gets Heat for Detaining Turkish Scholar

(RFE/RL)–The trial of a Turkish student who was arrested on June 17 on charges of attempting to smuggle historic Armenian books out of the country is set to start–despite growing international resonance with more than 200 scholars from the United States–Turkey–and Armenia reportedly having signed an open letter to President Robert Kocharian calling for their colleague’s immediate release. The letter warned that his imprisonment could "raise serious doubts as to whether Armenia encourages independent scholarly research on its history."

Among its signatories are Turkish historians Taner Akcam–Murat Belge–Halil Berktay–as well as publisher Ragip Zarakolu and one of Turkey’s most famous novelists–Orhan Pamuk. They have all described the mass killings of Ottoman Armenia’s as genocide despite threats and condemnation from the Turkish establishment.

The first Turkish academic to be granted access to Armenia’s national archives–Yektan Turkyilmaz is prosecuted under Article 215 of the Armenian Criminal Code that calls for between 4 and 8 years’ imprisonment for the contraband of anything ranging from antique books to weapons of mass destruction. He was detained at Yerevan’s Zvartnots airport while boarding a plane bound for Istanbul.

Turkyilmaz–who is fluent in Armenian and several other foreign languages–carried 88 Armenian books which he bought or was presented with in Yerevan. Seven of those books–including a 17th century Bible–were particularly old and required government permission in order to be taken abroad. The doctoral candidate told investigators and his mother that he was unaware of that requirement.

"After all–books like that are available for sale in Armenia," one of his Armenian attorneys–Vartuhi Elbakian said.

"Yektan bought them without violating the law," argued the other lawyer–Hrair Ghukasian.

Individuals detained while trying to smuggle cultural treasures have rarely been imprisoned in Armenia. Such cases usually end in heavy fines and the confiscation of those artifacts.

In a separate message to President Kocharian last week–Duke University president Richard Brodhead said–"As the leader of a great country–you have the ability to intervene in this matter and to determine the appropriateness of the actions of your government and the Armenian prosecutors and police."

Adding his voice on August 2 was former US Senate majority leader Bob Dole–known for his staunch advocacy of Armenian issues. In a strongly-worded letter to Kocharian posted on–he demanded that Turkyilmaz be released "at once," saying that the Criminal Code article used against him is "unique in the community of free nations."

Dole warned that failure to release Turkyilmaz would further tarnish Yerevan’s already negative image in the West. "Your detention of Yektan for seven weeks on any grounds would draw attention to failings in Armenia’s democratic evolution," he said. "To detain him on grounds as dubious as these calls into question Armenia’s commitment to democracy in the first place."

"Your treatment of Yektan makes Armenia look bad –with good reason," he added. "Armenia has many friends in the United States–but we cannot and will not defend the indefensible."

The academic’s mother–Gulsin Turkyilmaz–pleaded with the authorities in Yerevan on August 8 to set him free and end his controversial prosecution.

After visiting her 33-year-old son in a maximum security prison in Yerevan where he has been kept since his arrest on June 17–she said–"I hope that they won’t imprison him…if he knew that [he is violating Armenian laws] he wouldn’t do that."

"Yektan would never do any harm to this country," she added.

Turkyilmaz was allowed to see his mother the day before the start of his trial–which is expected to be attended by representatives of Duke University in North Carolina where he is pursuing a PhD in Ottoman history.

Turkey’s government has still not officially commented on the prosecution of the Turkish national. Turkyilmaz is among few Turks who have publicly challenged Ankara’s vehement denial of the Armenian genocide. n.


Discussion Policy

Comments are welcomed and encouraged. Though you are fully responsible for the content you post, comments that include profanity, personal attacks or other inappropriate material will not be permitted. Asbarez reserves the right to block users who violate any of our posting standards and policies.