Activists Slam Turkish Publisher’s Conviction

ISTANBUL (Reuters) – Activists condemned on Thursday the conviction of a Turkish publisher under a controversial law which Ankara reformed just two months ago in a bid to satisfy EU deman’s for greater freedom of expression.

Writers’ organization International PEN said the conviction of Ragip Zarakolu for insulting Turkey showed that Ankara’s reform of penal code article 301 was meaningless.

The reform removed a reference to "insulting Turkishness," for which dozens of writers including Nobel Laureate Orhan Pamuk had been put on trial — but it is still a crime to insult the Turkish nation and state. Justice Ministry approval is now needed to open a case.

"This is a very clear example that the so-called amendment of 301 is good for nothing. It was just a bad joke," International PEN chief Eugene Schoulgin told Reuters, adding that there were more than 80 such cases pending against writers and journalists.

Turkish writers had warned before the April amendment that they would continue to be targeted by nationalist prosecutors.

"This court decision seems to bear out our worst fears that the changes to the law won’t necessarily make a difference," said Human Rights Watch’s Turkey researcher Emma Sinclair-Webb.

The ruling AK Party defended the changes to article 301 saying that other members of the European Union, which Ankara wants to join, have similar rules. Brussels welcomed the reform as a step forward but called for further moves.

Turkey has several other laws limiting free speech and this week a popular tran’sexual singer, Bulent Ersoy, was on trial for "turning people against military service" for commen’s she made on television, local media reported.

Publisher Zarakolu was sentenced to five months in jail, convertible into a fine, but will appeal, Schoulgin said. Zarakolu was not available to comment.

He was tried for publishing a translation of a book about the Armenian massacres, which Ankara denies amounted to genocide. George Jerjian’s "The Truth Will Set Us Free" is a call for reconciliation between Turks and Armenia’s and tells the story of how a Turk saved the writer’s Armenian grandmother.

Pamuk was also tried for his commen’s about the Armenian massacres, but his case was dropped. Armenian-Turkish editor Hrant Dink was convicted under 301 for his calls for reconciliation between Turks and Armenia’s before he was shot dead in Istanbul by a teenage nationalist last year.


Discussion Policy

Comments are welcomed and encouraged. Though you are fully responsible for the content you post, comments that include profanity, personal attacks or other inappropriate material will not be permitted. Asbarez reserves the right to block users who violate any of our posting standards and policies.