Israel is ‘Main Threat’ to Middle East Peace, Says Erdogan

Israel's President Shimon Peres , right, looks on as Turkey's Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan makes a point while speaking during a session at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, Thursday Jan. 29, 2009. (AP Photo/Michel Euler)

PARIS (AFP)–Persisting in his harsh criticism toward Israel, Turkey’s prime minister said on Wednesday that Israel is the main threat to peace in the Middle East, marking a new low in deteriorating relations between the two allies who once had close military and political.

“If a country uses disproportionate force in Palestine, in Gaza – uses phosphorous shells – we’re not going to say ‘bravo,’” Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan declared at a breakfast meeting in Paris, referring to Israel’s deadly January 2009 attack on the Gaza Strip. Operation Cast Lead left around 1,400 Palestinians dead and destroyed thousands of homes.

Erdogan said Israel’s justification for the offensive was based on “lies” and cited a report by U.N. investigator Richard Goldstone, a South African judge who accused both Israel and Palestinians of war crimes.

“Goldstone is a Jew and his report is clear,” the Turkish leader told reporters invited to meet him at the Paris Ritz Hotel. “It’s not because we are Muslims that we take this position. Our position is humanitarian. It’s Israel that is the principal threat to regional peace,” said Erdogan speaking in Turkish, through a French interpreter.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu hit back at what he said were Turkey’s repeated attacks. “We are interested in good relations with Turkey and regret that Erdogan chooses time after time to attack Israel,” he said at a Jerusalem news conference held to review his first year in office.

“It is a regrettable occurrence which I don’t think serves the interests of stability and improved relations in our region,” said Netanyahu, adding that he had not discussed the issue with Erdogan.

Erdogan’s remarks came after Israel’s firebrand foreign minister likened him to the leaders of Libya and Venezuela. On Tuesday, Ankara “vehemently condemned” remarks attributed to Israeli Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman that compared Erdogan to Muammar al-Gadhafi of Libya and Venezuela’s Hugo Chavez.

Israeli Web site Ynet quoted Lieberman as saying on Monday that Erdogan is “slowly turning into Gaddafi or Hugo Chavez” and added: “It’s his choice. The problem is not Turkey, the problem is Erdogan.”

This spat followed tensions caused when Israel’s deputy foreign minister Danny Ayalon gave Turkey’s ambassador a public dressing down in January to protest a Turkish television series that criticized Israel.

After having kept Oguz Celikkol waiting, the envoy was made to sit on a low couch and the Turkish flag was removed from their table. Ayalon had pictures taken of the humiliating scene, infuriating Ankara.

One year after the Gaza battle, in a memorable outburst, Erdogan stormed out of a debate at the 2009 World Economic Forum in Davos after telling Israeli President Shimon Peres: “You know well how to kill people.”

Turkey is currently a member of the U.N. Security Council, which will soon have to decide whether to follow French and U.S. pressure to impose tougher penalties on Iran over its nuclear program.

At the Paris meeting, Erdogan pointed the finger at Israel’s undeclared stock of nuclear warheads, arguing that the fact that it had not signed the Non-Proliferation Treaty, or NPT, should not exempt it from international safeguards.

“Is this situation logical?” he demanded. “Should not being a member of the NPT mean you can do whatever you like every day?”

He repeated his opposition to sanctions against Iran, which Western capitals accuse of secretly seeking a nuclear bomb, insisting the International Atomic Energy Agency has found no hard proof of Tehran cheating.


Related posts

Discussion Policy

Comments are welcomed and encouraged. Though you are fully responsible for the content you post, comments that include profanity, personal attacks or other inappropriate material will not be permitted. Asbarez reserves the right to block users who violate any of our posting standards and policies.


  1. raffi said:

    We hope to hear the same critisisem from Erdogan when the Azeri leader treat to wage a war on Armenian

  2. Arny Handelman said:

    Erdogan blaiming Israel is the same old canard–that Israel is the main obstacle to peace in the middle east. Israel is not the cause of Shias killing Sunnis, Hamas killing Fatah, Syria invading and controlling Lebanon, Iraq vs Iran wars, etc etc.
    It's a complicated situation, but the overriding simple obstacle to peace is the Arab and Muslim virulent hatred of Jews and refusal to accept Israel's right to exist, and especially to exist as a Jewish state. Are Israel's peace treaties with Egypt and Jordan obstacles to peace. Israel would make all kinds of concessions if it's right to exist as a Jewish state were universally recognized. That isn't going to happen.

  3. Lusik said:

    In my opinion here are the pillars of Israel-Turkey bonding.

    1. Israel will retain Turkey as its satellite for as long as Turkey exists as a country on the world map. Turkey is a good substrate for growth. Jews people worked hard and long enough (for few centuries) to make it happen.

    2. Occasionally, some “Erdogan”-s and “Lieberman”-s have to come forward to “challenge” this unique bonding. There is some “good” in that – “polemics” and “difficult” periods only refresh relationships. Right now, for instance, Israel is busy with establishing Turkey's image of a Muslim-world-spokesman. Israel would not mind few “tough” words said here or there.

    3. Who is more just, or less criminal? Wasting your time! In both countries, both concepts are corrupted heavily and exist only for diplomatic rhetoric. Commercialization of Holocaust brings tons of kaleidoscopic goods, denial of the Armenian genocide goes along with Turkey buying an image of a human right fighter.

    What to do? Remember Sos Sargsian in movie Dzori Miro (Or, Voltaire's Candid). Water your garden. Yours.

Leave a Reply to Lusik Cancel reply