Armenia Slams PACE Over ‘Disgraceful’ Karabakh Panel

YEREVAN (RFE/RL)–A senior Armenian lawmaker strongly condemned the Council of Europe’s Parliamentary Assembly (PACE) on Tuesday for resuscitating an ad hoc “subcommittee” on the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict over vehement Armenian objections.

Davit Harutiunian, who heads the Armenian parliamentary delegation at the PACE, accused the Strasbourg-based assembly and its Turkish president, Mevlut Cavusoglu, of anti-Armenian bias. “The assembly has disgraced itself with such an overtly biased approach,” he said.

The subcommittee had first been set up following a PACE resolution on the conflict adopted in 2005. Its activities were effectively frozen in the following years.

Cavusoglu has sought to revive the panel supported by Azerbaijan since taking over as PACE president in January 2010. He has argued that its existence is envisaged by the 2005 resolution and dismissed Armenian fears that he will use it to push a pro-Azerbaijani solution to the Karabakh dispute.

The PACE’s decision-making Bureau approved Cavusoglu’s initiative on Friday. The Bureau also elected a Spanish parliamentarian, Jordi Xucla i Costa, as subcommittee chairman.

Harutiunian stood by the official Armenian line that the Karabakh conflict mediation is the exclusive prerogative of the OSCE Minsk Group and that any attempts to interfere in this negotiating format are counterproductive. He said the PACE is unfit to deal with thorny issues like Karabakh’s status, security guarantees and return of occupied territories.

“As for humanitarian issues, they are also part of the negotiating package,” he told a news conference. “Setting those issues aside and discussing them separately won’t help the package itself.”

The lawmaker, who also heads the Armenian parliament committee on legal affairs, claimed that the subcommittee will only serve as a new setting for bitter recriminations between the conflicting parties. “Instead of thinking about how to put our relations on a more civilized plane and looking for ways of civilized debate … we are creating a new platform for trading accusations,” he said.

It is expected that the Armenian and Azerbaijani delegations in Strasbourg will each be represented in the revived subcommittee by two members. Costa has yet to comment on its work schedule.

Naira Zohrabian, another Armenian member of the PACE, claimed on Tuesday that Cavusoglu’s main expectation from the panel is to draft an “anti-Armenian” resolution on the Karabakh conflict. Zohrabian earlier called for an Armenian boycott of its activities.

Harutiunian did not rule out such possibility. “We will talk about what we are going to do when the right moment comes,” he said. “But one thing is clear. We are definitely not going to participate in anything that could jeopardize the negotiating process. That we have serious concerns to that effect is also clear.”

Meanwhile, Armenia’s leading opposition groups, who are also against the subcommittee’s revival, blamed the Armenian authorities for the development. They said Harutiunian and pro-government members of his delegation have spent most of their time in Strasbourg justifying government crackdowns on the Armenian opposition and trying to avert PACE sanctions against Yerevan.

“Prevention of sanctions against the authorities has been deemed far more important than creating a more favorable atmosphere for the Nagorno-Karabakh issue. So the result should have been this,” Stepan Safarian of the opposition Heritage party told RFE/RL’s Armenian service.

Another of Armenia’s deputies to PACE, Zaruhi Postanjyanthe of the Heritage party, similarly blamed the authorities for the sub-committee’s revival, saying that the government should have struggled against the decision long ago. “We had to prevent Chavushoglu from assuming the PACE chairmanship,” she added.


Discussion Policy

Comments are welcomed and encouraged. Though you are fully responsible for the content you post, comments that include profanity, personal attacks or other inappropriate material will not be permitted. Asbarez reserves the right to block users who violate any of our posting standards and policies.


  1. Simon said:

    This sort of thing will stop only when Armenia *****retaliates***** by refusing to attend meetings with Azerbaijan over Artsakh.

    As long as Armenia just sits around and lets Turkey and Azerbaijan do these things, and lets its soldiers get picked off like sitting ducks by Azeri snipers, then nothing will change and respect for Armenia will continue to plummet. How would you like to be on the front lines and let Azeris pick you off?

    I would not doubt if Russia, which is working closely with Turkey these days – and also working to get as much Azeri gas as it can in echange for selling out Armenian – is going along with these acts by Turkey and Azerbaijan.

    How long must we endure this Armenian government?
    How long must we endure political parties who go along with this behind the scenes?

  2. Clive Rich said:

    Any kind of mediation can only work if the mediating person or entity is perceived as neutral. If one party believes the mediator is biased then the mediation will not work. That sounds like a big problem here. Having a Turkish president of PACE being perceived to be anti-Armenia is bound to cause problems, even if that is not the reality.