Jerusalem Armenians Outraged at Jews-Only Parking Lot

Armenian priests in Jerusalem's Old City (photo by Matthew Karanian)

JERUSALEM (Haaretz)—Armenian residents of Jerusalem’s Old City are protesting a municipal decision to designate a parking lot in the area solely for Jews, although part of it stands on land belonging to the Armenian Patriarchate.

Parking is a major problem in the Old City, and some residents of the Jewish Quarter claim it is one reason secular families have been moving out. One of the parking lots serving this quarter is adjacent to the Armenian Quarter and is partially built on land owned by the Patriarchate, though the land has been leased by the Jewish Quarter Development Company since the 1970s.

For decades, the parking lot was open to all, though Jewish Quarter residents paid far less for a parking sticker than their Armenian neighbors. But around two years ago, Armenians were forbidden to park there.

“One day I came home from work and the lot was closed,” said Mussa Marizian, an Armenian Quarter resident whose windows overlook the parking lot. “The quarter’s management decided we shouldn’t park there; they just got rid of us. Jews who live in the Muslim Quarter are allowed to park there, but I, who live right on top of the parking lot, am not allowed.”

The development company subsequently asked the municipality for a waiver to enable the lot to be permanently used for parking, even though it is zoned as open public land under Jerusalem’s master plan of 1978.

On Thursday, the city’s planning and building committee approved the waiver, over the protests of both Armenian residents and the Patriarchate’s representative, attorney Mazen Qupty, who argued that most of the land was owned by the church.

“It was hard to hear the very inconsiderate arguments made by the people of the Jewish Quarter about the needs of their Armenian neighbors,” said Yosef “Pepe” Alalu, the Meretz deputy mayor, who voted against the waiver. “How can it be that the parking lot used to be open to all but now Armenians cannot enter?”

The Jerusalem Development Company said that less that 10 percent of the parking lot’s land was leased from the Patriarchate, and that the lease was for 99 years.

“The Armenians have a roomy parking lot 150 meters from that spot,” the company said. “The request for exceptional use was a procedural issue to renew the parking lot’s operating license and the objections were legally rejected.”


Discussion Policy

Comments are welcomed and encouraged. Though you are fully responsible for the content you post, comments that include profanity, personal attacks or other inappropriate material will not be permitted. Asbarez reserves the right to block users who violate any of our posting standards and policies.

One Comment;

  1. Thomas said:

    This is a completely ridiculous article that has nothing to do with the facts of the situation.

    There are NO religious restrictions on where people can park. Not everyone who lives in the “Jewish Quarter” is Jewish, and not everyone who lives in the “Armenian Quarter” is Armenian (though in the latte case, the vast majority are).

    Here is the real situation, which is exactly the same in most cities through out the world: Each neighborhood in the city has a parking lot. Residents in each neighborhood can apply for a permit which allows them to use the lot. (Boston in the US has a similar policy – parking is restricted in most areas to people who live there).

    Only residents of the Armenian Quarter can use the lot in that Quarter. That has been the case for many years and is still the case now. The rule in the Jewish Quarter, however, has been different. Everyone – not just residents of the Jewish quarter – could park there (though residents of the Jewish Quarter did pay lower fees).

    Because the parking lot is overcrowded, the decision was made to limit the lot in the Jewish Quarter to residents of that Quarter – JUST LIKE THE PARKING LOT IN THE ARMENIAN QUARTER IS LIMITED TO RESIDENTS OF THAT QUARTER.

    Amazingly, some people are objecting that the can’t continue to use both parking lots, when all along their neighbors have NEVER been able to do so!

    This isn’t about religion, it’s about parking. And selfishness. And the racism of news sites that bizarrely and inappropriately use the word “Jew” to refer to the ethnically mixed residents of the Jewish Quarter.

    In all, this story is a lie, and those who wrote and published it are racist liars who will go to any lengths, no matter how absurd, to blame Jews for problems of their own making.