Playground Gear at Center of Glendale City Council Race

The old playground equipment at Glendle's Maple Park
The old playground equipment at Glendle's Maple Park

The old playground equipment at Glendle’s Maple Park


The Glendale City Council on Tuesday voted to discard playground equipment, which Councilmember Paula Devine had hoped the city would donate to a school in Artsakh.

Devine and Councilmember Frank Quintero opposed the motion to destroy the playground equipment, while councilmembers Vartan Gharpetian and Vrej Aghajanian were joined by Mayor Ara Najarian in support of destroying the playground gear.

Glendale resident, attorney Garo Ghazarian, spoke during public comments announcing that the Tufenkian Foundation had submitted an official letter requesting the playground equipment for a school in a village in Kashatagh, Artsakh, where the foundation is refurbishing a high school in its continued efforts to repopulate the liberated territories in Artsakh.

Ghazarian explained that during a fundraiser he hosted at his residence in April for the Tufenkian Foundation, Devine proposed donating the playground equipment at Maple Park, which was slated for replacement due to a provision in Glendale that requires replacing such gear every 12 years. The new Maple Part All Inclusive Playground Project was unveiled last week and funded by Development Impact Fee funds and designed by Shane’s Inspiration.

During Tuesday’s Council meeting, Devine said that per city staff reports, the playground equipment, which she wants donated, has been deemed safe and can be used for another five years. Najarian and Gharpetian contended that giving old and what they called dilapidated equipment to Armenia would put children there at risk and would not be appropriate, proposing instead to raise funds and acquire similar gear that is made in Armenia, which they said would benefit the local economy and not be cost prohibitive due to transportation and assembly costs. Devine announced that another charity had pledged to cover all costs of the transportation and assembly.


A similar vote was held in the spring, when Devine was joined by then Councilmember Zareh Sinanyan to support the effort to send the playground equipment to Artsakh, while the other councilmembers opposed the measure, based on similar concerns.

“Armenians might be poor but they are not beggars,” said Gharpetian at the council meeting to emphasize that donating second-hand gear might be frowned upon in Armenia, and in a way look bad for Glendale.

It was Aghajanian’s motion to discard the equipment that was put to vote and it passed 3 to 2.

Devine and Gharpetian are running for reelection in March and this issue seemed to kick-start a campaign season, which promises to be eventful, to say the least.

In a telephone interview with Asbarez on Wednesday Devine said she “was stymied” by the Tuesday’s vote. “I was making an effort to help and was turned down by my Armenian colleagues and was saddened by that.”

Calling the council decision “an insult,” Devine asserted that the equipment was safe and only had cosmetic issues, which could be fixed right away, that the Tufenkian Foundation, a reputable organization, wanted the gear for one of its projects.

“There are places in Armenia—there are villages—that are not getting the equipment and we are here for them. This is the Diaspora and I am supporting the Diaspora,” Devine told Asbarez adding that as a city councilmember she serves the entire community, with the Armenian population being an important part of it.

“I know what the Armenian community does for [its] homeland. I respect that and I want to be a part of that,” said Devine.

“I am sorry that it ended up that way,” said Devine. “I had high hopes. It deeply saddened me. I truly regret that.”

Gharpetian believes the issue is “one hundred percent politicized.” In a telephone interview with Asbarez Gharpetian said with this move, Devine was attempting to compensate for not supporting other efforts such as the renaming of a portion of Maryland Avenue to Artsakh Street and the approval of the Armenian American Museum.

“With all due respect, this is all political,” said Gharpetian. “She [Devine] is trying to compensate and make up for the votes she made against Artsakh Street and the museum.”

“If they want to make a playground a campaign issue so be it. I don’t want dilapidate equipment to go to Artsakh,” added Gharpetian.

“At the end that is still going to be Glendale’s equipment, I think we can do better. And we will,” Mayor Najarian told Asbarez in a telephone interview when asked whether donating the equipment now and raising funds in the future for another playground should have been considered. “Someone somewhere would be getting that old equipment. I would rather get them new equipment.”

Najarian was confident that within “30 to 60 days” enough funds would be raised to acquire the new equipment, which would be manufactured in Armenia and “boost the local economy.” He said he anticipated Gharpetian to make a relevant announcement in the coming weeks.

“Three Armenian want the best equipment for the kids out there,” said Najarian of his two fellow Armenian councilmembers.

“Paula has an election coming up and she is motivated to be very ‘hayaser’ to the community. I don’t fault her for that. There is better ways for that. We will invite her to take part in the fundraising. Let her brag about that,” added Najarian, inserting the political slant into the conversation.

“It is always sad to see politics taking precedent over pupils, and in yesterday’s case, politics seemed to trump the opportunity to help the Armenian students of Artsakh,” Ghazarian, who spoke at Tuesday’s City Council meeting, told Asbarez in an email.

“The Maple Park playground was not being replaced because it was old or dangerous. As stated by city staff and in the reports to council, the playground was replaced because the city had received a new Shane’s Inspiration playground. If it was dangerous and/or futile, it would not be up for discussion or be requested from the Tufenkian Foundation, as claimed by some councilmembers,” stated Elen Asatryan, former Chair of the Glendale Parks, Recreation, and Community Services Commission

“It is unfortunate and unacceptable that councilmembers decided to play political football and based their final vote on who is giving and receiving credit. It certainly looks like election season has officially begun in Glendale and the ones left to lose here are not just the children of Artsakh and Armenia, but the residents of our jewel city led by council members who have turned the political process into their own personal playgrounds,” added Asatryan.

Discussion Policy

Comments are welcomed and encouraged. Though you are fully responsible for the content you post, comments that include profanity, personal attacks or other inappropriate material will not be permitted. Asbarez reserves the right to block users who violate any of our posting standards and policies.


  1. State of Emergency said:

    “I was making an effort to help and was turned down by my Armenian colleagues…”? Her colleagues are US citizens and therefore Americans. Does Devine’s ethnicity or background ever come up during conversations??

    • Paula Devine said:

      This is an excellent observation and question. The simple answer is YES. One recent example of this can be found in the subject report on the Playground Equipment where the Mayor, in what I believe to be a very positive way, states that “she is motivated to be very HAYASER to the community. This comment certainly addresses my ethnicity, as an “American” non-Armenian. Another example occurred when I made the motion as an “American -non-Armenian” to approve the Armenian-American museum and my colleagues quickly pointed out that they, as American Armenians, should have made the motion instead of a “non-Armenian”.

  2. Paula Devine said:

    Thank you, Mr. Khachatourian for the objective and comprehensive article. You truly captured, understood and objectively reported the reality of the Council action regarding the Playground Equipment. Although you can report on only what you are told by the people you interview, “for the record”, I need to make you and your readers aware of the fact that the comments made by Mr. Gharpetian regarding my “trying to compensate and make up for the votes she made against Artsakh Street and the museum” are not true. In regard to Artsakh Street, I did NOT vote against renaming the street. On the evening of the vote, after hearing both sides of the arguments for and against the renaming and after reading the Planning Commission recommendation, I ABSTAINED from voting with the comment that I wanted to have staff come back with alternatives for recognizing and honoring the Artsakh name, without actually renaming the street, which may have financially impacted many businesses. Bottom line — my abstention was not a vote against Artsakh Street — it was a vote which said I will make a final decision after I have all the facts and have explored all the alternatives.

    In regard to the museum, while I did vote no on the preliminary design of the museum during the Stage I “design review” process, because of some design/appearance issues I believed should have been addressed, I NEVER HAVE AND NEVER WILL VOTE AGAINST THE MUSEUM PROJECT. A review of the minutes and the video of the July 31, 2018 and August 14, 2018 council meetings should refresh Mr. Gharpetian’s memory that it was I who moved for approval, with a second by Mr. Gharpetian, every motion and resolution for the EIR, VARIANCE, STAGE II DESIGN REVIEW and the GROUND LEASE and it was I who introduced the ordinance for approving the GROUND LEASE. Further, it was I who moved for approval, with a second from Mr. Gharpetian, of the museum ground lease. Bottom line — my words and actions both on and off the dais, together with the financial commitment I have made to the project, should leave no doubt in anyone’s mind as to my support for the museum.

  3. Mary Najarian said:

    I can’t believe people are making a big political issue on a playground set. Let me give you my experience sending Playground Equipment to Armenia. Seven years ago a friend of ours, Mr. Arsen Sanjian purchased ten brand new playground equipment in Los Angeles, and donated to schools in Yerevan. Medical Outreach took care of the shipment cost. It took three months for the equipment to get to Armenia. Mr. Sanjian, my husband and I were there when the shipment arrived and after unforeseen situations with installations, the playground sets were installed. Two years ago I went to Nor Kharpert Nursery school to see the one of the donated playground equipment that we had installed only three years ago, to my dismay it was in very poor condition – one single chain on the swing set was broken and the children could not use it even though it could have easily been repaired. It needed painting, it was rusty,and dirty. No upkeep had been done.
    This year, in June of 2019, I was in Armenia and visited Nor Kharpert for a new project. Ofcourse I went to the school yard and unfortunately the playground equipment we had installed was gone. The weeds had covered the area that once a brand new beautiful swing set stood. I respect the concern about charitable donation to Armenia, but to make a political issue out of one used playground equipment is waste of every one’s time. (I hope the faith of the other nine not the same.) Just for your information there is a company in Gumri that manufactures Playground Equipment.