Ankara under Fire over Armenian Conference Cancellation

(AFP/EUObserver)–Turkey came under fire Thursday for halting a landmark conference questioning the official line on the mass killings of Armenia’s under the Ottoman Empire–as European Union diplomats warned that Ankara’s democratic credentials had taken a serious blow.

Istanbul’s prestigious Bogazici University–where the gathering was to open Wednesday–put off the event after Justice Minister Cemil Cicek accused the participants–Turkish academics and intellectuals who dispute Ankara’s version of the 1915-1917 massacres–of "treason." Cicek condemned the initiative as "a stab in the back to the Turkish nation" and said the organizers deserved to be prosecuted.

The Genocide–one of the most controversial episodes in Ottoman history–is rarely discussed in schools and the aborted conference would have been the first by Turkish personalities to question the official stand on the events. Several countries have recognized the massacres as genocide–a theory Turkey fiercely rejects–and Brussels has urged Ankara to face its past and expand freedom of speech.

"The remarks of the justice minister are unacceptable. This is an authoritarian approach raising questions over Turkey’s reform process," a diplomat from an EU country said on the condition of anonymity.

"Now it is a real watershed. We expect government action to correct Cicek’s remarks," he said. "It’s up to the government to decide what to do. Doing nothing would be also a choice–but certainly not in favor of Turkey’s EU membership prospects."

"Since iek delivered his remarks under his title of justice minister and government spokesman at Parliament–the bloc would accept his remarks as the Turkish government’s position towards freedom of expression," one EU diplomat emphasized.

Another EU diplomat regretted the postponement of the conference because it "would have reflected the evolution taking place in Turkish society." The EU is looking forward for the conference to be rescheduled–he said–adding: "The Europeans will keep on insisting that civil society has a great role to play in Turkey."

The Turkish media too lashed out at the justice minister–saying his outburst cast a pall on freedom of expression in the country and played into the hands of a mounting Armenian campaign to have the massacres recognized internationally as genocide.

"Zero tolerance to freedom," the Radikal daily trumpeted on its front page–while Milliyet’s headline declared: "Democracy takes a blow."

"What–really–is treason? To hold a conference in order to start a debate in Turkey on a Turkish problem debated almost everywhere in the world–or to brand as ‘traitors’ people who may think differently at a time when Turkey is waging a battle for democracy in the face of many obstacles?" wrote columnist Murat Celikkan in Radikal.

"Cemil Cicek should resign as justice minister and if does not–he should be forced to do so," he said.

The EU expressed regret concerning "the mixed messages" coming from Turkey.

"We are aware of the tragedy in 1915. We hope that now–thanks to the EU prospect it will be possible to create a climate of confidence with the Armenia’s," a spokesperson for the European Commission said.

This is why "we expect that such a seminar will be held in the future–as the academic point of view is highly valuable when discussing these historical issues," she added.

However–the spokesperson declined to speculate on possible consequences for the launch of EU talks–due on October 3.

"A clear agreement on starting the talks was reached by the Council [member states]–the decision was taken at the highest political level," she said.

"The European Commission continues to monitor the situation and will issue a statement in its next [enlargement] report on Turkey," the spokesperson concluded.

Some countries–particularly France–which has a large Armenian population–have pushed for a tough line on Turkey in regards to Armenia.

The EU has said it wants to see Turkey improve ties with neighboring Armenia before it begins EU entry talks later this year. Some European officials have gone further–saying Turkey must acknowledge wrongdoing before starting talks.

"This strengthens the hand of those outside Turkey who say–’Turkey has not changed–it is not democratic enough to discuss the Armenian issue,’" said Hrant Dink–editor of the Armenian weekly Agos and a conference participant.

"It also shows there is a difference between what the government says and its intentions."


Discussion Policy

Comments are welcomed and encouraged. Though you are fully responsible for the content you post, comments that include profanity, personal attacks or other inappropriate material will not be permitted. Asbarez reserves the right to block users who violate any of our posting standards and policies.