PBS Response to ANCA ‘Unacceptable’

WASHINGTON–DC–The Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA) called a response from PBS Co-chief Program Executive Jacoba Atlas on the ongoing controversy surrounding a misguided panel featuring Genocide deniers "dismissive" and "unacceptable" Tuesday–urging PBS to meet with ANCA representatives to resolve the growing controversy.

ANCA National Board Member and Western Region Chairman Steve Dadaian first contacted Atlas on February 14–asking for a meeting to discuss the largely taxpayer funded public television station’s plan to air a 30-minute round-table discussion featuring known genocide deniers Justin McCarthy and Omer Turan. The panel would follow a one-hour documentary–titled [The Armenian Genocide,] by Andrew Goldberg of Two Cats Productions–to be made available to PBS affiliates nationwide on April 17.

While no meeting date has yet been set–Atlas’ February 24 response restated PBS’s affirmation of the Armenian genocide. "Implicit in PBS’s decision to accept [The Armenian Genocide] for distribution is its recognition that the overwhelming majority of historians and news organizations affirm that the Genocide took place," stated Atlas.

The letter continued–however–justifying the distribution of the genocide denial panel–stating that–"Most Americans do not understand what happened to Armenia’s; too often news organizations have ignored this part of world history. We strongly believe in the power of truth to come through in debate. We strongly believe in the ability of the American public to discern that truth."

Atlas dismissed comparisons to running a denial panel following a documentary on the Holocaust–stating–that "With all due respect–the comparison is not entirely analogous. Germany has fully accepted responsibility for the Holocaust–paid reparations–made apologies–met with survivors–and teaches about it in its schools. As you know–this is not the case with the Armenian genocide."

The ANCA’s response–issued by Dadaian–takes to task the flawed argumen’s presented by PBS. Referring to Atlas’s "dismissive" response as "unacceptable," Dadaian again asked for an opportunity to meet with Atlas and outlined the community concerns.

In reference to the argument that Turkey’s ongoing refusal to accept its past somehow forces a panel discussion featuring deniers–he asked if the same standard would be applied to a documentary on Darfur. "Following the logic of your decision–the next time Frontline does a documentary on Darfur–will you be providing the Sudanese government or its surrogates a forum to deny that what is being committed there is genocide?"

The ANCA letter went on to note that "earlier this year your network broadcasted ‘Hidden Turkey’ a ‘cultural and historical’ piece which presented a sanitized version of Turkey’s history without once mentioning the Armenian genocide or even the presence of the Armenian people on those lands for over 2,500 years until 1915. Why then–being a network which knows the truth–did you not follow that show with a panel discussing the Armenian genocide and how 1.5 million Armenia’s disappeared from those lands?"

Dadaian restated the basic tenet that–"There can be no tolerance for giving a national stage to those who choose to deny the Armenian genocide for the sake of political expediency just as there would be no tolerance to providing a forum to those who would deny the Holocaust or any such horrific crime."

Media controversy surrounding the misguided PBS decision continues to grow–with the Washington Post–New York Times–LA Times–Glendale News-Press–and Agence France Presse providing continued coverage of the story. Two PBS affiliates–Los Angeles KCET and Mountain Lake PBS in Plattsburgh–NY–have already pledged not to give Genocide deniers air-time–refusing to run the panel discussion.

A New York Times report that New York’s affiliate–WNET–would run the round-table–elicited a protest in front of their headquarters on Saturday. Congressman Anthony Weiner (D-NY) was joined by Armenian National Committee of New York (ANC-NY) activists and Armenian Americans to urge the PBS affiliate not to broadcast the panel.

Representative Weiner was unequivocal in his condemnation of WNET’s decision. "The Armenian genocide is a matter of history. No one should be given a forum to dishonor its 1.5 million victims. WNET should maintain the integrity of this documentary by pulling the panel discussion," said Weiner. The House Member has been an outspoken advocate for Congressional recognition of the Armenian genocide–cosponsoring two resolutions (HR 316 and HCR 195) currently under consideration in Congress.

The ANCA WebMail campaign continues to grow as thousands of concerned viewers from across the US send letters to PBS urging them to drop the denialist panel. Most recently–the ANCA WebMail campaign was featured on multi-platinum–Grammy-winning band System Of A Down’s website. Individuals interested in adding their voice to the campaign can do so by visiting: capwiz.com/anca/issues/alert/?alertid=8486526&type=CU

An on-line petition campaign–started by Armenian Tidorts–currently has over 14,000 signatories. To participate in the petition campaign–visit: www.petitiononline.com/pbspanel/petition.html


Discussion Policy

Comments are welcomed and encouraged. Though you are fully responsible for the content you post, comments that include profanity, personal attacks or other inappropriate material will not be permitted. Asbarez reserves the right to block users who violate any of our posting standards and policies.