How Low Can You Go?

garen_mainNo, I’m not singing a line from that song about limbo, you know, the game where you bend backwards and walk under a bar. The topic is Christine Essel and her contortions.

You’ll remember that Essel is Paul Krekorian’s opponent in the December 8 Special Election to fill the vacant 2nd Council District seat in the City of Los Angeles. You’ll also recall that on October 17, she attended an event hosted by Genocide-deniers. As if this wasn’t bad enough, now our intelligence is being insulted by her “explanations” of that event. I hope some of her Armenian supporters read this and give her an earful. Some of them are significant names. They are media folks, so their early financial support of Essel is not particularly surprising. She too comes from that background. Some other Armenians’ support though is more puzzling. These comments are based on the list of her contributors available online (HERE)

But far more interesting and relevant to this article is the presence of one key name— Ergun Kirlikovali —on her contributors’ list. You may recognize this guy’s name. He’s probably the preeminent, non-academic, Genocide denier in the LA area and California, if not the U.S. He’s been at it at least since the days when California was working on adopting legislation to integrate Armenian Genocide instruction in its curriculum, back in the 1980s. He’s also had letters published repeatedly in the LATimes over the years. He’s also the president-elect of the ATAA (Assembly of Turkish American Associations), not an organization noted for its Genocide recognition advocacy. One of its Board members was a sponsor of the event, according to the LAWeekly, in its piece about this situation.

Since the event, and probably in response to the play it got in the Armenian and non-Armenian media, Essel has released a statement. In it she states that she’s always supported Genocide recognition. She also professes “deep respect” for us. More’s the irony, you’ll see why. Asbarez also reported that Tom Berman, her campaign manager, emphasized that the infamous event was only a “meet and greet”, not a fundraiser. So how does he explain the Kirlikovali contribution, reported by the Essel campaign as deposited on October 22nd? That’s suspiciously close to the amount of time it would take for the mails to deliver a check or an event host to deliver to the campaign what he/she received. Also, I was told that last week, one of the Armenian newspapers in Constantinople, Marmara, re-reported from Yeni Shafak, one of the Turkish papers, that the Essel campaign, bowing to the Armenian lobby’s pressure had returned all the contributions from the event. We all know how unreliable the Turkish media can be, so this has to be taken with a grain of salt. But if it’s true, it sure calls into question Tom Berman’s assertion.

Not only are we supposed to disregard these last pesky financial facts, but also we’re supposed to be so dumb as to not figure out what she tried to pull. Essel knew she stood to get few Armenian votes, for obvious reasons, in a district with a fairly large Armenian population that will vote overwhelmingly for Krekorian. This is much as a Jewish or Black candidate would draw from his/her fellows in an election against a candidate from another group. So, Essel tried to pull a fast one and got busted. She figured, “No votes, but I can probably get some bucks from the Turkish side” and chose to go to the deniers’ sponsored event. This would be akin to, in the other two examples I give, going to a neo-Nazi or KKK hosted event.

Essel’s sincerity is brought into further question in light of the obviously sarcastic remark, reported in the LAWeekly: “The Essel campaign does not refuse to meet with people on the basis of their ethnicity”. Gee whiz, golly, wow, I wonder who was advocating that approach? It’s a nice ploy, diversionary tactic, but one which speaks to the cynicism of this whole project. Condemning neo-Nazis and KKK members is significantly different from proposing to not meet with all Germans or people from the former Confederacy.

It’s time Christine Essel comes clean, apologizes to the Armenian for the sequence of affronts, and denounces the deniers by returning any funds she’s received and publicly calling them out for what they are and do.


Discussion Policy

Comments are welcomed and encouraged. Though you are fully responsible for the content you post, comments that include profanity, personal attacks or other inappropriate material will not be permitted. Asbarez reserves the right to block users who violate any of our posting standards and policies.


  1. Jda said:

    Kirlikovali is more than just a denier. He is a straight up racist who uses Nazi language to describe Armenians. On the day Hrant Dink was assassinated he accused Armenians of killing him. He described the Armenians of 1915 as “backstabbers”, the same epithet Nazis used in 1933. He wrote that their deaths reminded him of a joke about a dead fly.
    He wrote that the average Armenian wants to kill any Turk on sight.

    Google his name with Pepto Bismol handy

  2. S. Yilmaz said:

    Sorry Garen, at least Christine, whatever racial background she comes from, does not practice Dashnak Radicalism like Paul Krekorian. Many noted Turkish Americans which ran for office do not practice racial supremacism like many Armenian American candidates for office like Paul Krekorian in Los Angeles, David Krikorian in Ohio, and maybe Nevada Congressional Candidate Danny Tarkanian. You guys know if you run for office, you guys will put your racial supremacist agenda and it will cause a lot of racism like what happened to the Latinos in the past and the African Americans in the past. Why is it that many people in racial extremeist sites like Stormfront support the “Hye Tahd” and why do Armenians have no problems having ties with Ahmadinejad? Why did Armenians in Iran not revolt against the Terrorist Ayatollahs? What about the Armenians in Lebanon? Oops, I am sure they have ties with Hezbollah. Learn how to be like Artin Penik and Edward Tashji, they are non-hateful and they don’t have unrealistic demands and they are able to move on from the past. What about Migirdic Agop as well. Heck my name dad had an Armenian classmate at an Istanbul college named Garo Karakashian who thought diasporans like yourself were racists in the 1970s for terrorizing Turkish originated people worldwide, not just politicians and Turkish association leaders, but everyone of Turkish background.