Historical Commission on Genocide ‘Unacceptable’ To Sarkisian

YEREVAN (RFE/RL)–President Serzh Sarkisian has reportedly rejected as “unacceptable” the idea of a joint Turkish-Armenian commission to study the Armenian Genocide without official Turkish recognition of the crime.

“The creation of a [Turkish-Armenian history] commission would make sense only if Turkey finally confessed its guilt,” he said in an interview with the German magazine Der Spiegel published over the weekend. “After that scholars would be able to jointly determine the causes of that tragedy.”

In two protocols signed last October, the Armenian and Turkish governments agreed to set up a joint commission tasked with expediting the normalization of their historically strained relations. It would be divided into several “subcommissions” specializing in various areas of mutual interests.

One of those subcommissions would engage in an “impartial scientific examination of historical documents and archives.” This was widely seen as an official euphemism for a joint examination of the Armenian massacres.

Official Yerevan has been at pains to assure Armenian critics of the protocols that the panel would not seek to determine whether the massacres constituted genocide. Turkish leaders have implied the opposite, however.

“The main thing for Ankara is only to delay decisions,” “Der Spiegel” quoted Sarkisian as saying. “Every time the parliaments or governments of foreign states try to adopt genocide resolutions, they would say, ‘Let’s first wait for the findings of the historical commission.’”

“Setting up such a commission would mean calling into question the fact of the genocide perpetrated against our people,” he said, echoing the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, a key opponent of his conciliatory line on Turkey.

The idea of a Turkish-Armenian history commission was first floated by Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan in a 2005 letter to then President Robert Kocharian. The latter rejected the proposal as a Turkish ploy designed to scuttle greater international recognition of the Armenian genocide.

Shortly after taking office two years ago, Sarkisian indicated that he is ready, in principle, to embrace the idea. “We are not against the creation of such a commission, but only if the border between our countries is opened,” he declared during a June 2008 visit to Moscow.

The apparent policy shift in Yerevan cleared the way for an unprecedented rapprochement between the two nations that culminated in the signing of the Turkish-Armenian agreements.

Sarkisian acknowledged in the magazine interview that the rapprochement is now “unraveling.” “The Turks are constantly demanding concessions from us. But that is not possible,” he said, referring to Ankara’s linkage between Turkish ratification of the protocols and a resolution of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict.

Der Spiegel: In his interview with Der Spiegel, speaking about the Genocide which had taken place during World War I, Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan stated that “there can be no talk of genocide.” Why cannot your neighboring country come to terms with its own past?

Serzh Sarkiaisn: Recently another statement was made that the Turks couldn’t have possibly committed the Genocide and the Turkish history is “bright and clear as the sun.” The Turks are opposed to the definition of the event as Genocide. However, Ankara is not the one to decide on this issue.

Now Erdogan is even threatening to expel thousands of Armenians illegally residing in Turkey.

Unacceptable statements such as that one conjure, up in our nation, the memories of the Genocide. Unfortunately, such statements articulated by Turkish politicians come as no surprise to me.

Sarkisian’s Der Spiegel Interview

SPIEGEL: Mr. President, in 2008, you attended a football match between your two countries together with your Turkish counterpart. It was a sensation at the time. Do you regret having invited the president of Turkey to your capital?

Sarkisian: No. I am convinced there is no other alternative but for Turks and Armenians to cooperate. We wanted to break through centuries of hostility. It was clear to me from the beginning that it wouldn’t be an easy process.

SPIEGEL: Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan told SPIEGEL that on the topic of Armenians killed by Ottoman troops during World War I, “There can be no talk of genocide against the Armenians.” Why does your neighbor have such difficulty with its own history?

Sarkisian: Mr. Erdogan has also said that Turks are not capable of committing genocide, and that Turkish history is “as clean and clear as the sun.” Turkey resists classifying the massacre as genocide. But no matter how great Turkish resistance may be, this is not a question that is up to Ankara to decide.

SPIEGEL: Now Erdogan is even threatening to expel thousands of Armenians living illegally in Turkey.

Sarkisian: For my people, such unacceptable comments evoke memories of the genocide. Unfortunately, these comments don’t surprise me, coming from the mouth of a Turkish politician. We don’t need to look very far back in history to find comparable declarations. Similar voices got loud in 1988 in what is today Azerbaijan. Dozens of Armenians died in the resulting pogroms in Azerbaijani cities like Sumgait and Baku.

SPIEGEL: How should the international community act on this question?

Sarkisian: The world must react decisively. America, Europe — Germany, too — all the countries that were involved in the process of Turkish-Armenian rapprochement should take an official stance. If every country had already recognized the genocide, Turkey wouldn’t make these kinds of statements. What gives reason for hope is that many young people in Turkey as well are protesting against these tirades. There’s a new generation growing up there, and the political leadership has to take their opinions into account.

SPIEGEL: Turkey also accuses you of blocking progress — Ankara says you prevented the formation of a joint historical commission. Why are you against this idea?

Sarkisian: How could such a commission work objectively, when at the same time in Turkey, anyone who uses the term “genocide” is persecuted and punished? Ankara is only trying to delay decisions. Whenever a foreign parliament or government approached Turkey with a request to recognize the genocide, the response would be, “Wait for the results from the commission.” Creating such a commission would mean questioning the fact of genocide against our people. We’re not prepared to do that. A commission would make sense if Turkey would admit its guilt. Then historians could work together to uncover the causes that led to this tragedy.

SPIEGEL: The genocide took place 95 years ago. Why is its recognition so important for Armenia today?

Sarkisian: It’s a question of historical justice and our national security. The best way to prevent the repetition of such an atrocity is to condemn it clearly.

SPIEGEL: You can see Mount Ararat, Armenia’s national symbol, from the windows of your residence. Today, the mountain is inaccessible, on the other side of the Turkish border. Turkey fears demands for land and compensation. Do
you want Mount Ararat back?

Sarkisian: No one can take Mount Ararat from us; we keep it in our hearts. Wherever Armenians live in the world today, you will find a picture of Mount Ararat in their homes. And I feel certain that a time will come when Mount Ararat is no longer a symbol of the separation between our peoples, but an emblem of understanding. But let me make this clear: Never has a representative of Armenia made territorial demands. Turkey alleges this — perhaps out of its own bad conscience?

SPIEGEL: Your borders with Turkey and Azerbaijan are closed, while Iran and Georgia make difficult neighbors. Isn’t it more important to break out of this isolation than to fight endlessly with Turkey over the genocide?

Sarkisian: We don’t tie the opening of the border to recognition of the genocide. It isn’t our fault if the rapprochement fails.

SPIEGEL: Turkey wants to make the opening of the border dependent on progress on the issue of Nagorno-Karabakh. Armenia fought a war over this region, which was claimed by Azerbaijan after the collapse of the Soviet Union, but where the majority of inhabitants are Christian Armenians.

Sarkisian: Turkey wants continuous concessions from our side. But that is not possible. The most important matter is implementing the right of Nagorno-Karabakh’s population to self-determination. In my opinion, if Azerbaijan would recognize Nagorno-Karabakh’s independence, the question could be resolved in a matter of hours. Unfortunately, Azerbaijan appears to want to solve the problem through force. The Azerbaijanis still believe they can annex Nagorno-Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan. That would mean, though, that within a very short period of time it would become impossible for Armenians to remain in Nagorno-Karabakh.

Why were the states in the former Yugoslavia able to obtain independence? Should Karabakh be denied the same rights — simply because Azerbaijan has raw materials like oil and natural gas at its disposal, as well as Turkey as its patron? We don’t think that is fair.

SPIEGEL: Would Armenia agree to extensive autonomy for Nagorno-Karabakh within Azerbaijan, the way it was under the Soviet Union?

Sarkisian: Of course not. Giving Karabakh back to Azerbaijan would lead to the expulsions of the Armenian population within a very short period. Nagorno-Karabakh was never part of independent Azerbaijan. The region wasn’t associated with Azerbaijan until a 1923 decision by the Communist Party’s Caucasian Bureau, under pressure from Stalin. If Karabakh were to become part of Azerbaijan, one would have to, at the very least, restore the Soviet Union. I don’t think anyone seriously wants that.

SPIEGEL: Turkey has been pursuing European Union membership for decades. Is membership a goal for Armenia too?

Sarkisian: Europe’s values are attractive for us. That’s the reason we’re currently reforming our administration, following the European model, of course. We know very well we must solve problems if we want to become a full-fledged member of a system. How long that process takes depends on us — but also on the EU.

SPIEGEL: Your country shares a border with Iran. How do you assess the global community’s conflict with Tehran?

Sarkisian: We’re watching with concern. Iran is one of only two land routes that connect us to the outside world. Everyone in Armenia knows that if Iran hadn’t kept the border open during the war, there would have been supply shortages for our citizens. The situation was similar during the Five-Day War (South Ossetia war) in 2008, when rail connections through Georgia were disrupted. We’re building a pipeline and a rail line together with Iran.

Interview conducted by Benjamin Bidder in Yerevan, Armenia. Translated from the German by Ella Ornstein.


Discussion Policy

Comments are welcomed and encouraged. Though you are fully responsible for the content you post, comments that include profanity, personal attacks or other inappropriate material will not be permitted. Asbarez reserves the right to block users who violate any of our posting standards and policies.


  1. barkevasadourian said:


  2. Jean-Louis Tourikian said:

    I support president Sarkisian 100%. He is handling a very difficult situation with class and strength. Keep up the good work.

    • W. R. Leigh said:

      Would you be the J.L. Tourikian who attended the University of Missouri in the early 1960’s and lived in the St. Louis area? If so, I bring regards from an old aquaintance.

  3. KhachKavor Gevorg said:


    6 April, 2010 Yerevan,Armenia
    Thank You For Your Attention

  4. art hagopian@ hotmail.com said:

    I believed from the beginning that President Sarkissian clearly meant the subcommission to discuss the results of the genocide and not its veracity. It is beyong imagination that any armenian leader could do otherwise. It is unfortunate that the Turkish leadership is hiding their heads in the sand and do not see the glo bal recognition of the armenian genocide even among those who vote against its adoption by parliaments for other reasons.

    Art Hagopian

Leave a Reply to art hagopian@ hotmail.com Cancel reply