BY SHUNT JARCHAFJIAN
But it tastes good… But it costs less… But it’s what my grandmother buys… But what about the distributor… But what about other stores…. But what about in Armenia…
These are some of the things you hear when you confront consumers, store owners, or importers with the same question: Do you intend to stop selling Turkish products?
It’s a simple question, that has a simple solution… Just Stop!!!
Over the years, countless attempts have been made to resolve this wrong. Some led by the youth, such as the AYF and some led by the elderly, such as the women who went to Super King armed with paper and pen going isle to isle and writing “MADE IN TURKEY” on a piece of paper and taping it on the shelf above the Turkish products. Have these movements been successful? They have certainly had an affect on the individual, but have they properly addressed the overall problem, have they changed the rampant apathy that is present in our community?
The short answer is NO. We have not been able to address this problem on a community wide level. We have not been able to break through the wall of ignorance and make Armenians informed consumers.
What is so bad about purchasing Turkish products?
Well for one, you are helping the Republic of Turkey generate tax revenue that is used to commit crimes against humanity. Now we all know that the genocide happened over a hundred years ago, but did it really ever stop? Have the Turks finally established a government that protects the rights of its citizens, the rights of its minorities, have they addressed their wrongs? Has the Turkish government made amends with its past and paid its debt to the Armenians that it tried to annihilate? Has Turkey matured enough to know that killing minorities and appropriating the culture, history, artifacts, churches, and schools of the rightful inhabitants and descendants of the land they occupy is wrong? I think not.
It is unfortunate that only a handful of Turks have come to terms with their past and have presented a willingness to address the wrongs of their nation. Every single day the government of Turkey engages in cultural appropriation, persecution of religious and ethnic minorities, destruction of the cultural heritage of the true inhabitants of the Armenian Plateau, the Armenians, and other crimes against humanity.
When you purchase tomato paste that is made in Turkey, you are not just purchasing something to eat, you are subsidizing all the evil deeds that the Turkish government engages in.
When you buy Tukas, the most popular brand of Turkish tomato paste, you are helping Erdogan erase your past and shape the present, a world where Armenians, Greeks, Assyrians, and Kurds do not exist. A world where the Turkish empire extends from the Mediterranean to Mongolia, unifying Turkic peoples and nations to form a Pan Turkic empire. An empire that glorifies tormenting minorities and Islamic extremism. The modern republic of turkey is responsible for many crimes against humanity, the holocaust at Smyrna, the attack on Dersim Kurds, the occupation of Cyprus, ,the assassination of Hrant Dink, and the destruction of Armenian cultural artifacts , churches and cemeteries.
Tukas tomato paste, for example, is a Turkish company that was owned by the Turkish Armed Forces Pension Fund between 1967 and 2014. If you purchased Tukas tomato paste between those years, not only did you contribute to the tax revenue of the Republic of Turkey, you literally funded the retirement of the soldiers serving in the Turkish Armed Forces. Imagine that, a displaced Armenian, forcibly removed from their ancestral homeland, living thousands of miles away from the Armenian Highlands where they lived for thousands of years, and taking their hard earned dollars to the “Armenian” grocery store and making a donation to the pension fund of the Turkish soldiers currently occupying and pillaging their land.
Another Turkish product that is found in virtually all NON Turkish Product Free Zone stores are the ULKER brand crackers. A seemingly harmless product, just a few biscuits from the far east you might say. Well the truth is far worse. The Ulker company is a prime example of what happened to our stolen properties and how little the Turkish government has done to make amends. The Ulker company has a factory that is built on stolen Armenian Land. This is stolen Armenian land that belonged to the Armenian Church. After the genocide and the forced removal of our people, the property was controlled by the state, which later sold it to the Ulker company. The factory is literally built atop an Armenian cemetery. Not only did they kill and displace the living, they also dishonored the sacred hallowed ground of the cemetery and built a cracker and biscuit factory atop. It pains me to see an Armenian in a grocery store picking out this particular brand of biscuits to enjoy with their cup of tea. Is it really that hard to find another brand of biscuits, is the flavor and taste so out of this world that it is worth purchasing products from the people that desecrate our dead.
Turkey is a large country with a sizable economy. Will a few Armenians not purchasing a few crackers or a few jars of tomato paste bring down their economy? Probably not. Is it the right thing to do? Yes. Will the concerted efforts of all those that have felt the blade of the Turks on their necks, the Armenians the Greeks, the Kurds, the Lebanese the Syrians the Cypriots, deciding not to engage in commerce with a republic that has proven to be uncivilized and a destructive force in the region and the entire world, year after year, decade after decade, century after century, make a difference and change the overall dynamic? I think it will.
Purchasing Turkish products is a statement, it is a clear sign of a lack of a moral compass, it emboldens and enables Turks to continue pillaging, destroying and appropriating our culture without any ramifications. Not purchasing Turkish products sends a clear statement to the Turks and to the world, actions have consequences and until the wrongs of the past and present are addressed, we as human beings will not stand idly by and do nothing, we as a community believe in our right to return to our homeland and demand recognition, restoration and reparation for all past and present crimes.
If we cannot successfully remove Turkish products from our own stores who are we to demand that local and national entities and governments not invest and enable the Turkish state? How can we request that the state of California not invest its pension fund in Turkey? How can we file law suites against the US government for building an air force base atop stolen Armenian property (Incirlik US Air Force base). How can the Greeks demand for a unified and unoccupied Cyprus? We must end the hypocrisy and remember that demanding justice for the genocide is not accomplished by merely showing up at the Turkish consulate with an Armenian flag, but is accomplished through our own decisions and consumer choices as well.
Over the past few months, we have seen about 20 stores pledge to become “Turkish Product Free Zones” and remove products made in Turkey from their shelves. There is still a long way to go, but the simple act of asking your grocer if they have considered removing their Turkish offerings is sometimes all it takes. There are “TPFZ” Facebook pages popping up all over the world and hopefully soon we can proudly say that products made in turkey are not sold in community. You don’t need to sign up for anything, you don’t need to join any organization, all you have to do is be an informed consumer and educate those around you.
If we have no problem buying Turkish products, we ultimately have no problem with the occupation of our land. If we have no problem buying Turkish products then we have no problem with the destruction and desecration of our churches and cemeteries. If we have no problem with buying Turkish products then we have no problem with our own history being misappropriated and rewritten as though it belongs to some other tribe.
We are the descendants of people with thousands of years of remarkable accomplishments and contributions to the world, if we keep buying and selling Turkish products, we dishonor the past, present, and the future. If someone came to your home and forced you to live in one corner while the other 90 percent of your house as a factory, would you turn around and pay them to purchase products produced there? I think not. We are wise, we are cunning and we are innovative, I don’t see why we cannot come up with alternatives to these products.
The choice is yours, and what you do today will affect you and yours for years to come. Don’t be surprised if one day the turks tell you that they are natives of that land, and that Tigran the Great was a Turk. I know it seems ridiculous, but is it really more ridiculous than an Armenian purchasing Turkish products?
turkish apricots and other fruit and products are common here-linen too though have not seen or bought their crap – they ocuppy our arable lands- and stole all after raping and brutalizing before and after the genocide- a good turk is a dead one- the leaders-we take them down
Armenians in the USA help pay for Turkey’s military expenses with our federal tax dollars we pay.
Portions of these federal taxes are sent to Turkey as part of the billions of dollars that the US govt provides in military, economic & political aid every year.
The couple of million dollars, if that, that Armenians spend on buying Turkish products at the local Armenian or non-Armenian stores does not even come close to the billions of dollars in aid to Turkey that foreign govts, including those that say they support the recognition of the Armenian Genocide,
Our efforts should be focused on forming coalitions with other groups to work to cut aid to Turkey.
Excellent article. I applaud all the volunteers and youth organizations who for the past several years are promoting the Turkish product free zone idea, encouraging and rewarding the stores who are willingly participating in this campaign. I like to see an additional effort to promote the alternative. In some of the Armenian stores we can find Armenium brand tomato paste and also red pepper paste also Map brand tomato paste at competitive prices. Recently I also saw Ralph’s market selling Ararat sparkling bottled water. Walmart is selling pajamas made in Armenia and of course so many different Armenian products are sold here. So, in addition to stop buying Turkish products, with no additional effort let’s all promote “Buy Made in Armenia” and if there is no equivalent Armenian made, let’s buy made in USA.
The author of the article forgot to mention that there is an annual trade of goods worth more than 250.000.000 (two hundred fifty million) dollars entering Armenia from Turkey, which is a national disgrace for all of us as Armenians. Needless to say that the government of Armenia does not do anything to significantly reduce or better eliminate this volume of trade with our genocidal arch enemy. Any Armenian with a shred of self-respect and dignity should refrain from buying anything made in Turkey, even if a substitute to it is not found elsewhere.
Sadly I think we tend to overrate our cunning, wisdom and innovative qualities.
Our Armenians should help by carefully checking every product and first of all by not buying it which would put pressure on the store owner and the second step would be bringing it to the store owner. Think of it this way “every single dollar spent on buying turkish product turns into a bullet that kills our soldiers in Armenia”. It’s pathetic if any Armenian individual doesn’t pay attention to that and like a traitor, YES a TRAITOR, helps the turkish and Azerbaijan’s governments be more able to arm themselves to teeth and kill more of our people. Every single Armenian has this responsibility, as a duty, especially with such a large Armenian community in southern California and the largest being in Glendale, not a single turkish product should be sold/purchased. Turks are watching all of these bulletins and they forget what the reason for this is. I was born in Iran, third generation of Saroyan’s in Van. Only four survived out of the large extended family of 60. Grandparents became orphans, hidden in bags in deserts of Syria and Iraq, married at 14 by surviving relatives and moved to Iran. Why am I telling you all of this? It’s because the killings, massacres, RAPE, pillage and mutilations of 1,500,000 of Armenians didn’t occur easily. Anyway, the first guilty party for bringing turkish products are the importers, who sell them them to the groceries, who are the second guilty parties and then the buyers. This should stop completely dead in its tracks and YES I do practice what I preach. I check every single product before buying and only once I made the mistake of buying a product of turkey due to being in a rush. Although the money was paid but to make sure I don’t do it again, the product went into the trash directly with no hesitation. At the end, please remember our young soldiers at the front-lines of Armenia and Artsakh are not fighting and sacrificing themselves for nothing. PLEASE DON’T BUY TURKISH PRODUCTS. No matter which store it’s from, being an Armenian grocery or and American store.
Trader Joes sells dried fruit, marinated vegetables and honey products from Turkey. Check the labels, they do say country of origin
Thank you for writing this article! It is very important for Armenians not to buy ANY products made by turks because it is supporting the killings of Armenians and fuels their economy and well being of turks. Another item of turkish product is Mariani Ultimate Dried Apricots
STOP baying Turkish products.
Great article. Simple common sense…
Thanks Shant for this great researched article. Keep the fight.