BY ARA KHACHATOURIAN
Immediately after a judge remanded former president Robert Kocharian to custody on charges of breaching Armenia’s Constitutional order in relation to the March 1, 2008 post-election showdown between protesters and police, during which eight civilians and two police officers were killed, a group of parliament members began circulating a petition urging the court to release Kocharian on his own recognizance.
Initially, the petition was signed by 41 members of parliament who were members of former president Serzh Sarkisian’s Republican Party of Armenia, with Parliament Speaker Ara Babloyan and deputy speaker Arpine Hovhannisyan and Eduard Sharmazanov as the most prominent signatories to the document.
The petition was announced on the same day as Kocharian’s attorneys filed an appeal of the remand decision, which will be hear by a court in Yerevan on Thursday.
The final petition that was submitted to the court on Monday contained 46 signatures with three members of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation bloc—Ruzan Arakelyan, Armenouhi Kiureghyan and Romik Manukyan—and one members of businessman Gagik Tsarukyan’s bloc co-signing the document. The ARF and the Tsarukyan bloc are part of the current government led by Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan.
(On Tuesday, a group of Artsakh Parliament members also submitted a similar petition to Armenia’s Prosecutor General’s office calling for Kocharian’s release. By contrast there are no ARF members’ signatures on that petition.)
The ARF members’ signatures on the petition follow an announcement by the ARF Supreme Council of Armenia, which on July 27, the day of the Kocharian ruling, said that the while the party welcomed efforts to establish rule of law and eliminate the climate of impunity, if found that charges against Kocharian and other members of the government at the time have concerned them because they “may be interpreted as political persecution.”
Armenia’s chief investigator Sasun Khachatryan told reporters last week that the Kocharian’s remand was necessary for the unimpeded continuation of the investigation, emphasizing that while Kocharian was not seen as a flight risk, but could influence the investigation by exerting pressure on others involved in the process.
Speaking to Azatutyun.am on Tuesday, Armenia’s Deputy Prime Minister Tirgan Avinyan hinted that there may be consequences to the ARF’s and the Tsarukyan bloc’s decision to take part in the protest process. It should be noted that ARF Bureau member Spartak Seyranyan said on Monday that the party had not made an official decision to join the petition drive.
“It is their right and it is very important to emphasize the fact that the Special Investigation Service does not receive any instructions from the Executive branch. It acts independently, as does the Court of First Instance,” said Avinyan.
“The ARF, which is part of this government, should be well aware of the relations between the executive and the judicial branches,” said Avinyan saying the party’s statement after Kocharian’s remand “was unclear.”
“From day one we have said that the executive branch will not exert any pressure on the judiciary. No one calls the judge and tells him what to do. That’s unacceptable,” said Avinyan.
Arakelyan, one of the ARF signatories downplayed the petition’s implications on the ARF’s role in the government.
“This is a very normal political process,” Arakelyan told Azatutyun.am. “It does not contradict the fact that we are now part of the [governing] coalition and together with the current authorities are trying to… contribute to Armenia’s progress.”
“I think that this [stance on Kocharian] will not jeopardize the coalition because we do not undermine our agreement with the current authorities in any way,” added Arakeylyan.
(I will reserve comment on the maelstrom that the ARF’s announcement and its members’ signatures have created on social media. I will address the post-Velvet Revolution social media frenzy in the future).
Supposing that the new government is indeed respecting the concept of separation of powers—a novelty in Armenia given past instances of the executive branch’s interference in judicial matters—however, the legislative branch seems to have not gotten the memo.
There’s a larger question during this dustup: how will a petition by members of parliament impact the court’s ruling? And, why should Kocharian be set free from pre-trial incarceration? Neither the petition nor statements protesting the remand have clarified that. Only Kocharian’s attorneys have made a case, which will be heard in court on August 7.
Similarly, Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov’s comments last week, calling the arrests “political” is not only an infringement in Armenia’s domestic affairs, but also shows a similar disregard for the separation of powers—a concept that clearly is not adhered to in Russia.
For the sake of advancing the process of reforms and strengthening democratic institutions in Armenia, what all political forces, be they in the government or not, must aspire to preserve the separation of powers in Armenia to ensure that democracy will prevail regardless of who is charged and what the charges are.
So, “Is a Petition to Release Kocharian Necessary?” and what is the text?
Here we go again. Ever since Russia muddied the waters last week, justice has taken a rear seat. Once “closed-door” meeting between Putin and Pashinyan are concluded, Russia will lay the footwork going forward. No amount of righteousness or justice will get in the way of Mother Russia’s imperialistic ambitions. If corruption and power are the driving force behind their ambitions then that’s what Russia will use to pave the roads.
good coverage, Ara!
look at the names on the list and you’ll make the conclusion.
All those who believe in the rule of law not power must support the law when it does not discriminate against the most powerful and wealthy. When will our parliamentarians speak out when our poor and minorities have their right trampled.
Armenia needs Justice not vengeance.
Whst is going on in Armenia?
The arrest of former RAPresident its a disgrace, an infamy. Pashinian and Levon should also be arrested on charges of crowd incitement and disregard for the law surrounding the incidents of 2008. Pashinian the rabble rouser and head of the protesters was asked to withdraw the crowds before the presidential palace. He rejected the the request and egged the protesting mob forward ( while he cleverly gave orders behind the lines). This is a malicious political vendetta against the former RA president by the “revolutionaries Nikolai and Levon”. Unable to deliver on his outlandish promises and expectations to the people, Nikol will keep them busy and distracted with political persecution’s, and circus trials. The people are not stupid, they will soon awake to the fact of having been taken advantage and duped , capitalizing on their discontent with the previous administration , by the dulcet messages from Nikol and his associates.
Azad, Kocharyan made Armenia into a desert.
The petition to support corrupt Kocharyan is a shame for TASHNAGTSUTIUN. ARF leaders better start listening to the voices of the people. What the ARF leaders are doing in Armenia is very damaging for the party. This is not a good way of gaining popularity with the people of Armenia. As it stands, AYF is not a very popular Party by the people. Be careful, if ARf wants to gain political capital, they should change their policies and support justice in Armenia. Unfortunately, they are going about it the wrong way.
last time I checked there were 3 ARF members on the list of petition. I believe ARF needs to be Zoxovurdi Koxkin rather than the oligarchs, otherwise ARF will lose it’s credibility.
Thank you, Ara. Your Article is well though, logical and sincere. I also believe in the separation of powers between the Executive, Legislative and the judiciary branches. Since independence, the Executive/Presidents of Armenia did not respect the fundamental constitutional order of separations of power. In fact, all the three presidents abused their executive power and influenced the judiciary as well as the legislative bodies. The petition from the Republican Party legislative body sent to the judiciary for the release of Robert Kocahryan is a blatant violation of separations of power, no matter how you look at it. Anyhow, now that the judiciary has exercised its legitimate powers and turned down the petition, we hope this will serve as a bitter lesson to the Republican Party. Besides, as elected representatives of the people, these arrogant members of parliament were not representing or discharging the desire of the people they represent. For the record, Kocahryan is the most hated person in Armenia. The initiative taken by these Parliamentary Representatives has indeed violated the wishes of the people, therefore they were making a decision against the will of the very people they represent. As a caveat, these parliamentary representatives should not forget that it is these very same people that will elect them, the next time around. With such blatant violation and misrepresentation, it is unlikely the people will elect them as their representatives. Assuming a legitimate election process, it is very unlikely these mini-dictators will return to parliament.
Anyone who supports kocharian and hhk is not against president Levon Ter- Petrossian or Prime minister Pashinyan, but against the ARMENIAN people!